Forward, not backward. Up, not down. Better, not worse. New, not old. Equality, not inequality. Peace (sort of), not war (sort of). Good, not bad. Positive, not negative. George Washington. Abraham Lincoln. Franklin Roosevelt. A New Direction™. A New Direction™. A New Direction™. Money. A New Direction™. My opponent. A New Direction™. Money. A New Direction™. A New Direction™. A New Direction™. Thank you. God bless.Last night I went to a little private grip-n-grin with Bob Casey, Jr., the pro-fetus, anti-Arab, Democratic senatorial candidate in Pennsylvania. His brief speech is reproduced above.
I didn't get a chance to ask him how he plans to accomplish what his web site calls "peace in the Middle East based upon Israel's security needs." Based on Isreal's security needs? I'm just sayin.
Anyway, it was another extraordinary example of the ineffectuality of liberalism in America: liberals do not field candidates, but they sure do vote for Democrats. I'm not a liberal myself, but you could probably persuade me to support one in an election, given the alternatives. Yet in state after state, you end up with your Bob Caseys and your Ned Lamonts, promising vaguely to ask "the tough questions" about Iraq and to "demand answers" and "accontability" from "this administration."
But what does any of this mean? We've asked the questions. We know the answers. This, more than anything, is a persistent misconception of the left. We don't need Senators who will hold hearings to discover what we already know, which is that the war on terror is a scam to expand the police powers of the state, the war in Iraq likewise, with an added soupçon of misapplied millennial political theorizing as part of the grand, hydra-headed Straussian project to lock the full scope of human endeavor in a Camp X-Ray-style cage and badger it with loud music and freezing showers until it tells us precisely what we've already decided we want to hear. We know these things. We don't need someone to ask the questions or get the answers.
We need someone who will repudiate in absolute and unequivocal terms the practice of waging aggressive wars, who will repudiate in absolute and unequivocal terms the practice of torture, and who, at this late date, will reaffirm that yes, indeed, the Great Writ is the foundation of our much-vaunted, little-practiced Western ideal of justice and the law. Believe me. Bob Casey is not this man.
Bob Casey is a man who must instead concentrate on disconfirming his constiuents' suspicion that his undoctrinaire, but nonetheless unshakeable, fidelity to a medieval concept of uterine ensoulment that damns to hell as murders the practitioners of abortion may possibly kinda sorta affect his public policy making. (Let them die of natural causes, and let god sort 'em out, he seems to be saying of the abortionists.)
80 comments:
Amen (if you'll pardon the expression).
Well written as always. But in this case TOO well written. It persuasively argues something that, while in clear evidence to intellectuals and liberals, really is not well known or understood by the public. To Wit:
We've asked the questions. We know the answers. This, more than anything, is a persistent misconception of the left. We don't need Senators who will hold hearings to discover what we already know, which is that the war on terror is a scam
YOU may already know this
_I_ may already know this
Any thinking person who has read and thought about Orwell may already know this
But the vast majority of the American public has barely a HS education. At best they have a 1:5 shot that they had to read Orwell, and most likely wrote a book report that spelled the title and author's name correctly and put Winston Smith and Newspeak somewhere randomly in the body and got a "Gentleman's C". And we all are witness to where that leads
So while your idea that
We need someone who will repudiate in absolute and unequivocal terms the practice of waging aggressive wars, who will repudiate in absolute and unequivocal terms the practice of torture, and who, at this late date, will reaffirm that yes, indeed, the Great Writ is the foundation of our much-vaunted, little-practiced Western ideal of justice and the law.
Is very much what we need from our elected representatives, FIRST they DO have to lay the groundwork for such repudiation. And the best way a politician can do that, is to have public hearings that refute assertions like
"We knew that Zubaydah had more information that could save innocent lives, but he stopped talking. As his questioning proceeded, it became clear that he had received training on how to resist interrogation. And so the CIA used an alternative set of procedures. These procedures were designed to be safe, to comply with our laws, our Constitution, and our treaty obligations. The Department of Justice reviewed the authorized methods extensively and determined them to be lawful. I cannot describe the specific methods used -- I think you understand why -- if I did, it would help the terrorists learn how to resist questioning, and to keep information from us that we need to prevent new attacks on our country. But I can say the procedures were tough, and they were safe, and lawful, and necessary.
Zubaydah was questioned using these procedures, and soon he began to provide information on key al Qaeda operatives, including information that helped us find and capture more of those responsible for the attacks on September the 11th
Remember that Bush got as much as an 8% increase in approval ratings after this speech.
Unless you are a politician like Bob Barr or John McCain or Colin Powell, who's bona fides on national security are already lodged in the minds of the average American who struggled to spell 1984 - you HAVE TO FIRST PROVE to the American public that the above was just weasel-word bullshit.
Then and only then can you succesfully stand up and repudiate the US actions in a meaningful and effective way. Mind you, starting to do that repudiation earlier is important. But much as you and I and others who have a well tuned ear for the resonant sound of plopping organic matter, dislike it, the reality is that you can't effectively denounce the policies as a politician unless you get elected.
Wouldn't it be really easy to govern if everyone was smart, acted in their best interests and were respectful of others? You'd hardly have to govern at all!
Unfortunately, we live in the real world where even smart people do truly stupid things that are very self destructive. We live in a world where everything is not equally allocated, people have different talents and ambitions. There are toadies who will gladly glom onto those who would subjugate others, further increasing their power. We live in a reality where "acting in one's own interest" can paradoxically result in tragedy for everyone.
Governing is really hard in the real world. Trying to get elected is really hard in the real world. If we lived in the Utopian society, we'd be done and wouldn't have to bother ourselves with pandering and such.
"If you lived here, you'd be home by now"
I appreciate the sentiments IOZ, but it's really a comic book expose' where if - you'll pardon the expression - we just have to use our will and our green lantern ring will make it so (apologies to he of the unpronounceable last name)
Azael - Advocacy is not governance, and "governing is really hard in the real world" is the sort of dodge only applied as justification for the actions of an inherently corrupt enterprise. A business that tells its auditors that reconciling accounts is really hard in the real world, ergo our gross lapses in fiscal oversight and legal compliance are justified as necessary ad hoc, after-fact adjustments for impossibly complex circumstances. An excuse, in other words, but a poor one.
The task of governance can be complex in a large society, but adherence to a small set of immutable principles whatever the vicissitudes of circumstance is not. If we are to grant our governments the power to wage war and to enact legal processes against individuals, then we are obliged to enact, respect, and enforce limits that the exigencies and dangers of the moment don't, won't, and can't override. The right to know the charges against you is one of these.
To say: Well, electability in a society like ours demands hedged bets around such demagogically underminable issues; to say: Well, it's easy for you, IOZ, to defend the writ and denounce aggressive war because you don't have to get elected--to say these things is to admit that representative democracy has failed to uphold any meaningful principle of its invention.
It may well be that such democracy is a failure--is doomed to failure, even. Franklin thought so. As you've probably guessed reading what I write here, I'm increasingly convinced that it's folly myself. But if you're willing to accept that only compromised men can achieve and weild power on behalf of their constituencies, and tha a man who gives a few inches on habeus corpus, torture, or aggressive war is only doing so to prevent a slide of a mile, then what, really, is the point of any of this at all.
What I advocate on this blog, to the best of my abilities, and through the scrim of lot of verbal vaudville, is the very simple idea that every man is autonomous and inviolable, that the circumstances abridging his autonomy must be subject to the most stringent controls, and that yes, it is better for a thousand murderers to go free than for one innocent man to hang. I don't advocate these things because I expect that they'll help my candidates acquire sinecures in government. I advocate them to remind people that such principles exist.
Thanks for replying to my posts, though. You're a tough one. I hope you keep it up.
Cheers,
IOZ
But if you're willing to accept that only compromised men can achieve and weild power on behalf of their constituencies...
If representative democracy is indeed doomed around these parts, its demise will be due in no small part to the fact that the proletariat never had much use for such a thing in the first place, and never much wanted it either.
Unfortunately, ma petite crotte IOZ, your "compromised men" are maybe far less so than your average Thomas Jefferson in the eyes of the "typical American." After all, those annoying Inalienable Rights serve primarily as an obstacle to his joyful persecution of the Other. In fact, and quite ironically, the enshrinement of those principles as exceptionalist justification for their own violation in the name of this country's ill-advised messianism is quite possibly the only reason they've survived as long as they have.
Beside the point? Perhaps. But there it is.
No, sys, I don't think it's beside the point. I think you've very articulately expressed my own reservations, which I noted in passing above--the the enterprise may be doomed, inherently, inexorably, and by its own designing.
And yet?
buy diazepam 1mg lorazepam 10mg diazepam - diazepam 2mg insomnia
xanax online extended release xanax pills - buy xanax online from canada
buy zolpidem zolpidem 5mg pill identifier - zolpidem tartrate snort
buy xanax xanax overdose potential - generic xanax rating
lorazepam 1mg ativan generic trade name - ativan duration
cheap valium buy 1000 valium - complete list valium side effects
buy valium uk valium 10mg equivalent xanax - prozac (fluoxetine) and valium (diazepam) interaction
buy diazepam cheap buy diazepam 10mg india - 10 mg diazepam for dogs
zolpidem no prescription zolpidem cr side effects - zolpidem tartrate qualitest
purchase xanax xanax 620 - where to buy xanax without rx
where can i buy xanax online xanax dosage range - xanax side effects last long
buy xanax xanax effects when not prescribed - xanax with alcohol
generic xanax buy xanax online from canada - buying xanax without prescription'
buy xanax valium online florida xanax dosage vs valium - 2mg xanax to sleep
buy ativan ativan side effects blurred vision - ativan and alcohol withdrawal treatment
online soma buy soma shampoo - buy soma drug
buy valium cheap online valium pill sleep - valium effects- 2mg
buy valium online buy valium amsterdam - using valium for anxiety
c4ks84bd http://www.cheapisotretinoinforless.net/#isotretinoin-price - isotretinoin price isotretinoin without prescription
xn7bl2d5 http://www.cheapisotretinoinforless.net/#cheap-isotretinoin-online - order accutane online order isotretinoin
r0n6ks8f http://www.fatfreemind.com/#phentermine-37.5-mg - phentermine 37.5 mg phentermine 37.5 no prescription
not9js6f http://www.thepromise1073.com/#propecia-online-pharmacy - propecia online pharmacy propecia pills
yndo5g7b http://www.fatfreemind.com/#phentermine-online-no-prescription - phentermine online no prescription phentermine online pharmacy
dsc4hd7h http://www.jonathanornstein.com/#generic-lexapro - generic lexapro generic lexapro cost
gbdg7hw6 http://www.teabuzzed.com/#isotretinoin-price - isotretinoin price isotretinoin without prescription
dsc4hd7h http://www.jonathanornstein.com/#escitalopram-cost - escitalopram cost escitalopram no prescription
yndo5g7b http://www.fatfreemind.com/#buying-phentermine-online - buying phentermine online cheap phentermine
fo90nv0 http://www.yourambiencheap.com/ambien.html - ambien 10mg ambien cost , http://www.yourambiencheap.com/ambien.html - ambien cr ambien for sale
Xanax, or Alprazolam, is a medication that is used to help people who have panic or anxiety disorders. Panic disorders generally are a result of an overly active or overly excited brain. [url=http://androiddose.com/]xanax without rx[/url] http://androiddose.com/ - order xanax - Agoraphobia пїЅ If you have a fear of open spaces, Xanax can help treat the anxiety felt from being in a large, open space. This is to ease the transition into taking the drug regularly.
t6m2m6k7 http://www.pegasusweddingreception.com/#order-soma - order soma order soma online
While many people blame obesity on their genes or their metabolism, the simple fact is that obesity is caused by consuming more calories than are expended through physical activity. [url=http://www.poplease.com/]buy reductil online[/url] Poor eating habits have led to a significant portion of the worldпїЅs population being overweight. Obesity is defined as having a body fat level that is high enough that it leads to increased health problems and reduced life expectancy. Meridia can help solve the problem of obesity.
Patients should discuss any side effects with their doctor as they occur to determine Provigil continues to be the best medication for them. Doctors may also prescribe Provigil for the treatment of spastic cerebral palsy, ParkinsonпїЅs disease, opiod induced sleepiness, myotonic dystrophy, chronic fatigue syndrome, as well as fibromyalgia. http://www.courtarrestrecords.com/ - modafinil online no prescription Provigil side effects may include but are not limited to insomnia, agitation, anxiety, aggressiveness, confusion, tremor, sleep disturbance, nausea, and diarrhea. It may be used to treat ADHD, seasonal affect disorder which is also known as SAD.
l3m7n8s63h http://www.bestpriceprednisone.net/#cheap-prednisone-online - cheap prednisone online cheap prednisolone
l3m7n8s63h http://www.celebrexonlineoffers.net/#generic-celebrex-cost - generic celebrex cost generic celebrex no prescription
http://www.cheapcelexaoffers.net/#buy-celexa-online-no-prescription - buy celexa online no prescription purchase celexa
l8d92h4b http://www.celebrexpainrelief.com/#order-celebrex-online - order celebrex online order celecoxib
l8d92h4b http://www.isotretinoinhelp.com/#isotretinoin-online-pharmacy - isotretinoin online pharmacy isotretinoin pills
l8d92h4b http://www.klonopin365.com/klonopin.html - klonopin online pharmacy generic klonopin
l8d92h4b http://minersvillelibrary.com/#buy-finasteride-online-no-prescription buy finasteride 5mg http://oneandonlyeventsblog.com/#cheap-zithromax purchase azithromycin online
l8d92h4b http://www.ordanburdanhayattan.com/#buy-generic-topamax topamax sale http://www.877inmyzip.com/#buy-diazepam order valium
l8d92h4b http://www.celebrexpainrelief.com/#purchase-celebrex celecoxib cost http://witchesview.com/#buy-modalert modafinil online pharmacy
Hello, b7d9h3s6 http://www.bestpricenolvadex.net/#buy-nolvadex-no-prescription nolvadex no prescription http://www.levitrapillsforsale.net/#levitra-without-rx generic levitra 20mg
Hello, b7d9h3s6 http://www.acompliaforcheap.net/#buy-acomplia cheap rimonabant http://www.cheaplasixforsale.net/#lasix-for-sale cheap lasix without prescription
Hello, http://www.windowsphone7cases.net/#order-venlafaxine venlafaxine without prescription http://www.adipexdietpillcheap.net/#adipex-cost buy adipex online without prescription
Hello, http://www.bestpriceonlinepharm.net/premarin.html premarin cost http://www.nexiumgenericforless.net/#cheap-nexium-online nexium without prescription
Hi http://www.cheapdiazepamonnet.com/#valium-for-sale valium 5mg http://www.isotretinoinbestprice.net/#isotretinoin-for-sale cheap accutane
Hi http://www.noprescriptionfordietpill.net/acomplia.html buy generic acomplia http://www.meridiabestprice.com/meridia-without-prescription.html buy sibutramine
Friends, http://www.genericsoma4sale.com/#order-soma purchase soma http://www.crestoronlinesale.com/#discount-crestor rosuvastatin online
Friends, http://www.soma4lesscoupon.com/#soma-350-mg carisoprodol 350 mg http://www.neurontin4sale.com/#neurontin-for-sale buy cheap neurontin
Friends, http://www.365discountmeds.net/restoril.html temazepam cost http://www.neurontin4sale.com/#neurontin-for-pain buy neurontin online
Friends, http://cubanjewishrelief.org/#escitalopram-online cheap escitalopram http://www.365discountmeds.net/klonopin.html cheap clonazepam
Friends, http://www.yourcarinsurancelocal.com/california.html cheap car insurance sacramento http://www.neurontinmedicine.com/#neurontin-medication neurontin drug
Friends, http://www.ativanmedforsale.com/#lorazepam-without-rx ativan online http://www.happypharmsales.net/ www.happypharmsales.net/
Friends, http://www.rustopedia.org/#cheap-finasteride buy generic finasteride http://www.allegrabestdeal.com/#purchase-allegra-online buy cheap allegra
Friends, http://www.365discountmeds.net/restoril.html buy temazepam online http://www.prednisoneforless.com/#cheap-generic-prednisone generic prednisolone
Friends, http://www.imitrexneworder.com/#order-imitrex buy imitrex http://www.acomplia-bestprice.com/#cheap-acomplia acomplia sale
Friends, http://www.365discountmeds.net/restoril.html purchase temazepam http://www.neurontinmedicine.com/#generic-gabapentin purchase neurontin
Hello, http://www.healthcaremedsnorx.net/ www.healthcaremedsnorx.net http://www.isotretinoindiscount.net/#generic-accutane-online buying accutane online
Hello, http://www.medicinesnorx.net/ambien.html ambien for sale http://www.healthcaremedsnorx.net/accutane.html accutane online
Hello, http://www.antidepressantsnorx.com/zoloft.html zoloft for anxiety http://www.stratteraforsale.com/#strattera-sale cheap strattera online
Hello, http://www.topamaxfastrelief.com/#topamax-online purchase topamax http://www.isotretinoindiscount.net/#buy-generic-accutane accutane no prescription
Hi, cheap provigil http://www.provigilcheap.com/#provigil-no-prescription topamax pills http://www.topamaxfastrelief.com/#topamax-price
Hi, generic cymbalta online http://www.texasdieselinjection.com/#cymbalta-price prozac anxiety http://www.bestpriceprozac.net/#fluoxetine-20-mg
Hi, MoxoredapeTox buy finasteride online - finasteride online http://www.wheretobuymedsonline.com/propecia/
Adequacy Of Pharmaceutical Drug Trials prednisone sale - prednisone without prescription http://www.prednisone4sale.com/#prednisone-without-prescription
Web Resources Directory Sports Medicine order diflucan - diflucan without rx http://www.diflucansaleonline.net/#diflucan-without-rx , [url=http://www.diflucansaleonline.net/#fluconazole-without-rx ]fluconazole without rx [/url]
The Drug Angel Dust lexapro without prescription - lexapro without rx http://www.costoflexaproonline.net/#lexapro-without-rx , [url=http://www.costoflexaproonline.net/#order-lexapro ]order lexapro [/url]
Nontraditional Medicine buy cheap meridia - order sibutramine http://www.meridiaonlineorder.net/#order-sibutramine , [url=http://www.meridiaonlineorder.net/#meridia-diet-pills-online ]meridia diet pills online [/url]
tfv clomid pills for sale - cheap clomid online http://www.clomidonlinediscount.net/#cheap-clomiphene, [url=http://www.clomidonlinediscount.net/#cheap-clomiphene]clomiphene price [/url]
tmd clomid medication - clomiphene cost http://www.clomidonlinediscount.net/#buy-clomiphene, [url=http://www.clomidonlinediscount.net/#buy-clomiphene]buy clomiphene online no prescription [/url]
xrh buy strattera online - buy strattera online no prescription http://www.stratteraforsale.net/#buy-strattera-online-no-prescription , [url=http://www.stratteraforsale.net/#strattera-for-sale ]strattera for sale [/url]
Hello, clonazepam online no prescription - generic klonopin http://www.stationcoffeeandtea.com/#generic-klonopin , [url=http://www.stationcoffeeandtea.com/#buy-clonazepam-no-prescription ]buy clonazepam no prescription [/url]
3 cheap cymbalta - cheap cymbalta http://www.cymbaltaonlinerx.net/#cheap-cymbalta, [url=http://www.cymbaltaonlinerx.net/#cheap-cymbalta]cheap cymbalta[/url]
4, buy modafinil without prescription - provigil without prescription http://www.provigilonlineoffer.net/, [url=http://www.provigilonlineoffer.net/]buy modafinil online without prescription [/url]
Post a Comment