Tuesday, October 24, 2006

Kos!

The first impression is that it is very orange. The borders are orange. The hyperlinks are orange. Below the MSNBC banner ad, the masthead carries an all-orange picture of what appears to be a newsie raising old glory in a vaguely socialist-realist pose, the sort of thing you'd expect on a playbill for a revival of Waiting for Lefty. There's an ad exhorting purchase of the paperback Crashing the Gates, which "is one of the two best books I've read in years about the Democratic Party, its myriad problems and challenges," a blurb that implies more time--years!--spent pursuing explications of the most self-evident phenomena in American politics than anyone should spend. Below that this morning is an open thread dedicated to a YouTube video "of Ned Lamont walking to the debate site." Perhaps that sounds oddly prosaic for its own video feature. I assure you, it is not.

It begins with bagpipes and bagpipers in full kilt regalia. A crowd follows with signs, clapping and cheering. At 0:19 seconds, what appears to be a large crucifix passes, carried by someone in the crowd. Then a chanting crowd: "WE WANT NED!" Then a pickup truck with its flashers on, driving very slowly, with some sort of papier-mâché model in the bed, though it never gets close enough to make out. The effect is of the local lodge of Scotch Rite Freemasons taking a group of Democratic supporters through the Stations of the Cross. The header text crows, "Lieberman can only dream of generating this much attention and excitement over anything he did." If I were to dream such a parade, meanwhile, I'd seriously consider cutting back on the spicy food before bed. But it impressed the Kossites. "I can't believe that Lieberman is winning," seems to be the common thread in the thread, and this from a site that frontpages poll numbers all day. ("I don't believe the polls." "Wait till the real poll--the election!" That sort of thing.)

I followed a link to a recommended "diary" entry titled "Gullible Kossacks make asses of themselves." This sounds promising, I thought. It begins: "The TANG scandal should have taught us that we should not read stuff into stories that simply are not there." Not promising. I followed another link to something in the more panegyrical vein, which is the more common and accepted form of self-expression on DailyKos. "Thank You, Markos." "Forgive the title," writes nyceve, "it's what I feel. And if you don't like it, just imagine life without Daily Kos. Too awful to contemplate, right?" It's Heaven's Gate territory, and it degernerates:

For some time, I've wanted to write a diary, simply to thank Markos for all he has done to change the course of history. Make no mistake, history is being shaped here, every single day.

Daily Kos is a lifeline, a megaphone, a platform to press for deeply necessary change in the United States. Use it well, because millions of Americans are hurting.

I suppose I'm also saying for example to anyone who has a problem with say, the banner, forget about it. If Markos needs twelve banners so our voices will be heard, then let's have twelve banners

And lest I sound too emotional, I recognize as Markos says, DKos is not about him--he's correct. But though Daily Kos has his brilliant imprimatur stamped all over it, his voice, his megaphone is but one of many.

This leads to the next point. Are they listening? They damn well better, because we mean business.
A lifeline, a megaphone, and a platform. A bowl of shells, a spoonful of pudding, a pizza oven. A rocketship, and iceberg, a pine tree. It ends beatifically:
Thank you again Markos, for giving us the opportunity to take back our country.
That one was admirably covered by Michael J. Smith of Stop Me Before I Vote Again:
I. Lost Eden

Howard Dean may not be the very worst way to start your day, but anything worse would have to involve physical injury. His speech -- greeted with great enthusiasm, of course -- was interesting chiefly as a little tour through the alternative thought universe inhabited by liberal Democrats. Howard kept talking about "taking back" the country, "taking back" the party, "taking us back" to the high ideals -- of John F. Kennedy, forsooth. He must have used this phrase "take back" a hundred times. He even said the upheavals of the 1960s were an exercise in "taking back" America. He said we want open and honest government --or no, he said we want it "back."

Now this is very bizarre, when you think about it. When did "we" ever have the Democratic Party, or the country? When did they get taken away? By whom? How did that happen? Open and honest government -- when did we ever have that? Never, you say? Then how can we get it "back"? When did we live in this Eden that Howard wants to restore?

If God did not exist, Candide observes, man would have to invent him. This imaginary former state of grace is a necessary invention too. The Kosniks know that sometime in the last half-century, the Republicans acquired a decisive upper hand, and they know the country is going to hell in a handbasket. So far so good; but then they make a false step. They start with a conclusion -- restoring the Democrats to power would make things better -- and for there they reason backwards to the necessary premise, namely that we once enjoyed all these things they quite rightly want, and we lost them when the Republicans took over.

That's how it works for the audience, I think. But it doesn't seem likely that Howard Dean himself, or his colleagues in the Party apparatus, are subtle enough to have crafted such an appeal on the basis of their deep psychological insight. No, this "take back" mantra, for them, is simply a kind of Freudian slip. The takeback they have in mind is simply to take back a place at the trough for their office-seeking snouts. So the wish-fulfilment dream of the troops, and the unconscious self-revelation of the pols, dovetail in one of those beautiful, overdetermined conjunctures that nobody could ever have designed.
Smith doesn't come right out and say it, but there's a name for a political ideology based on a projected, utopian past that can only be reacquired through political acts whereby the cultural radicals are ousted and an imaginary old order restored: conservative.

Kos and his followers imagine themselves bolsheviks of Democratic liberalism, but their political ideology, such as it is, is deeply conservative. It serves up a unidentifiable, unspecified time of general well-being and social harmony, a status quo in which the only change that occured was "progress" in an exceedingly vague sense of a general improvement to the social and economic wellbeing of the society as a whole. It locates the rupture with that vision in certain political triumphs of its opponents, whom it accuses of revolutionarism. It dedicates its political actions to the recapture of such a past, which was taken away, and which must now be taken back. Things were better before, and once we go back, they'll be better in the future again.

In that confusion of verb tenses you find the abject failure of the dreaming insurgents of the Democratic party.

24 comments:

Will Divide said...

Though your point is taken, Henry Wallace was VP for four years, and was really only a few months away from being Prez. There once was a more optimistic era in our politics, though we can argue away the whys and wherefores for that.

As for the kossaks, I say it pays to dream, and they are not the enemy.

Lately I've been thinking that when smart people grab, they leave something for others. When stupid people grab they try to take everything for themselves. I would love a return to the time when smart people did the grabbing.

Adrian said...

"Kos and his followers imagine themselves bolsheviks of Democratic liberalism, but their political ideology, such as it is, is deeply conservative."


Actually Kos states that his blog is not ideological, but rather about getting Democrats in power. DailyKos is not about returning to the glories of yesteryear, blah blah blah. It is about power - how to get it, and once Democrats have it, how to maintain it. Hence his revulsion for DLC "strategists" - not for ideological reasons, but because they are ineffective at obtaining power.

As an aside, nyceve focuses her writing entirely on health care issues, and on those who are screwed over by health care, so it's not surprising that she goes a little overboard on her gratitude.

IOZ said...

Will: Point taken, though I'm not quite sure I buy entirely buy your Wallace example, especially the idea that a "more optimistic era" corresponds to what I wrote about the features of conservativism.

Adrian, thanks for stopping by. In response, I will tell you that taking political actors' statements about their own lack of ideology is naïve. I will tell you that if it is in fact the case that the purpose of Kos is to advance the fortunes of a political organization without regard to ideological content, then Kos is not only the laughable organization I lampooned, but a deeply pernicious one. "Power for power's sake" is, I believe, the expression for all that. You're confirming Michael Smith's assertion that the whole point of the enterprise is to put Democratic snouts back in the public trough, thank you very much.

As for "the glories of yesteryear," that isn't the point. The point is that the rhetoric of "taking back" a party, a people, or a country, is a conservative formulation. It suggests that there was once something of value that was lost and must be regained. It makes a mobilizing ethos out of a rupture with a past state of grace. You say that this is an unfair criticism because you don't actually propose that such a past state existed. Fine.

Then what the hell are you taking back?

Anyway, delighted to have you come by to offer your perspective. We mean it about the dogmatic slumbers. Yours and ours equally.

Adrian said...

IOZ - I think you and Michael Smith are reading too much into the rhetoric of "taking back the country/party." I think that rhetoric is being used because it sounds good, not necessarily because it reflects a desire to return to a lost paradise. What slogan should Kos/Dean use instead of "take back"? "Take over" implies, as you said, power for power's sake, which never goes over well. Rhetoric about creating something entirely new could be seen as too radical. I agree that "Taking back the country" is conservative/reactionary rhetoric, but this is a conservative country and that is what will work. And the disaster Bush has been for this country/planet makes rhetoric that appeals to a paradise lost even more effective.

Who's more cynical - me, who thinks that people consciously grab power, or you, who think people fool themselves with ideology? A rhetorical question.

Will Divide said...

I think it can be demonstrated to a rhetorical fair-thee-well that the 'radical' and 'conservative' poles have recently switched their political charge. It is now only dawning on many that the radicals have been the ones running things for the last six years.

As for nomenclature, I perfer reimagine over take back; but I know Dean would be pelted with quarters were he to say that in public.

I submit that there is a reimagining of the party taking place, in large degree on the basis of new info technology. The whole recent issue of well-funded Dem. campaigns giving money to poorer candidates in close races is, to me anyhow, a completely fascinating phenomenon. Last cycle it would have been impossible to conceptualize, next cycle it will be another way the party works.

Now that I think about it, the feeling surrounding "take back" comes in large degree from women's anti-rape Take Back the Night campaigns. You can also argue there that women never had the night in the first place, but the rhetoric does imply fighting for and grasping a greater measure of control over an intolerable situation.

Anonymous said...

I like it, thank you. :)


replicas louis vuitton

how to get cash advance from your paycheck

loan payday quick uk

loan overnight personal quick

advance cash fax no payday until

payday paycheck loan cash loan

Index Page

credit easy fast loan payday

emergency faxing loan no payday
24 hour payday loan

credit free online report score

See you later, thanks

Anonymous said...

Cute, very cute... Thanks man!


buy card master online phentermine

buy tramadol hcl

buy cheap soma online

tadalafil ups

buy cheap tadalafil

atarax drug

buy cheap phentermine online

Good Bye!

Anonymous said...

Finally the real thing - no more ripoffs! Enhancement Patches are hot right now, VERY hot! Unfortunately, most are cheap imitiations and do very little to increase your size and stamina.
Well this is the real thing, not an imitation! One of the very originals, the absolutely strongest Patch available, anywhere!

Check out the site http://www.seemoco.info for more info TODAY, you'll be glad you did ;)

Penis Growth Patch

______________________________________________
Our others products:
Ultra Allure Pheromones
Anatrim
Advanced Gain Pro Pills
Regenisis HGH

Anonymous said...

Keep up this great resource. Respect!

rapid weight loss pill


new diet pills on the news last week


Good Luck!

Anonymous said...

Hi
Linux software,news driver ,games
http://spdimon.info

G'night

Anonymous said...

Hi man! Thanks for the site!
online drug store
drug store pharmacy online
discount drug store online
canadian online drug store
cheap online drug store
prescription drug store online
canada online drug store
drug foreign online store
online drug store ultram
drug medication online prescription store
drugstore online
online drugstore
online drugstores
mexico online drugstores
1 drugstore online
canadian online drugstores
online drugstores spain
foreign drugstores online
See you tomorrow!
cheapest generic viagra

Anonymous said...

I like it, thank you. :)
zithromax 1g
zithromax
zithromax z pack
zithromax used for treating
zithromax as treatment for chlamydia
zithromax dosing instructions
zithromax medicine
zithromax as for treatment for chlamydia
zithromax dosage
alcohol and zithromax
zithromax no perscription
side effects of zithromax
zithromax azithromycin
zithromax no prescription
antibiotic zithromax
zithromax side effects
zithromax z-pak
zithromax 3 week course
See you soon!

Anonymous said...

Wow, man! Cool site!
effexor xr
effexor xr withdrawal
is effexor xr a good drug
effexor xr withdraw symptoms
effexor xr side effects
effexor xr weight loss
effexor xr withdrawal symptoms
effexor xr and eye problems
effexor xr withdrawals
generic effexor xr
effexor xr online
effexor xr 75mg side effects
alcohol and effexor xr
effexor xr generic
antidepressant effexor xr
effexor xr dosage
side effects of effexor xr
buy effexor xr
cheap effexor xr
effexor xr 37.5
effexor xr discount
effexor xr hearing loss
effexor xr treats depression
See you later, thanks

viagra said...

In 1998 a particular blue pill came as an angel that rescued all those tormented by the demon of erectile dysfunction. That blue pill was christened Viagra. Since then viagra has completely changed the scene of the treatment of ED. Nowadays one can even buy viagra online. Customers are reluctant to buy viagra from the local chemists for a varied number of reasons since the availability of viagra online. In order to lure the customers the online pharmacies also offer cheap viagra.

Anonymous said...

40 inch plus 8th street latinas all amateur movies all sites access big naturals boys first time cam crush captain stabbin cum fiesta cum girls dangerous dongs euro sex parties extreme asses extreme naturals first time auditions in the vip mega cock cravers mike in brazil mikes apartment milf hunter milf next door papi real orgasms round and brown street blowjobs team squirt top shelf pussy tranny surprise tuna party vip crew we live together wives in pantyhose 40inchplus 8thstreetlatinas allamateurmovies allsitesaccess bignaturals boysfirsttime camcrush captainstabbin cumfiesta cumgirls dangerousdongs eurosexparties extremeasses extremenaturals firsttimeauditions inthevip megacockcravers mikeinbrazil mikesapartment milfhunter milfnextdoor papi realorgasms roundandbrown streetblowjobs teamsquirt topshelfpussy trannysurprise tunaparty vipcrew welivetogether wivesinpantyhose

Anonymous said...

Hawaii warriors quarterback 2007 heisman award winner and top nfl draft pick plays with hawaii warriors. You can buy sports tickets for the hawaii warriors football games.

Colt Brennan
Colt Brennan bio
Quarterback Colt Brennan
2008 nfl draft Colt Brennan
Colt Brennan hawaii heisman
Hawaii Quarterback Colt Brennan
Colt Brennan Bio
sports tickets
bondage sex toys
buy sex toys buy sex toys
tickets
Hiroki Kuroda

sandra said...

Our Online Pharmacy doctors will evaluate your health information and provide you with a prescription, so you do not need a prescription from your regular family physician to buy viagra.

reggiewhite said...

Generic Cialis is a new group of medication which allows adequate sexual stimulation, relaxes the blood vessels of the penis and helps erection.

johnnysmith said...

Generic Cialis is an oral drug, used for treating male impotence, also known as erectile men's erectile dysfunction. Generic Levitra helps increase blood flow to the penis and may help men with ED get and keep an erection satisfactory for sexual activity.

Anonymous said...

Generic Viagra has helped millions of men with erectile dysfunction achieve improved erections. This pill is shown to help men get and keep an erection for successful intercourse.

Anonymous said...

generic viagra
generic viagra
online pharmacy
buy viagra
buy viagra online
generic viagra
generic cialis
generic viagra
buy cialis

Penis Enlargement Pills said...

Really you have done great job,There are may person searching about that now they will find enough resources by your post.I like this blog..

Anonymous said...

NtvQlf [url=http://cajackets.com/]canada goose[/url] PkeZqw IddJpf http://cajackets.com/ SyiGzi BlrFgf [url=http://dkjackets.com/] Canada Goose Jakker[/url] UxrUqe QcwDyu http://dkjackets.com/ XliBwj NjnQbm [url=http://jacketsparkaoutlet.com/] canada goose parka[/url] ZwrBlc AwqDoi http://jacketsparkaoutlet.com/ IfeFab PvaCvg [url=http://parkatoyou.com/]canada goose parka[/url] OceNmw PfaQjq http://parkatoyou.com/ ZrmJtq PndAqt [url=http://nfsaleukshop.com/] the north face sale[/url] UqmGhc KbzOou http://nfsaleukshop.com/ CfvVin VjzPws [url=http://nfjackets-sale.com/]North Face Jackets[/url] JmaTed NurYlu http://nfjackets-sale.com/ HsgGnk OacUnh [url=http://goosejackets-ca.com/]canada goose jackets[/url] QpuLfx TshYmm http://goosejackets-ca.com/ VrrZbi

Anonymous said...

UzmEgr [url=http://jakkerdk2013.com/]canada goose[/url] OozOon UcmJpn http://jakkerdk2013.com/ XvpHfp TjyIlq [url=http://goosejakkertono.com/] Canada Goose Norge[/url] YrqVvn PfaCdk http://goosejakkertono.com/ UbuAad EpiJoc [url=http://gooseoutletweb.com/] goose outlet[/url] RnbVhd GjkNos http://gooseoutletweb.com/ AsaNiq SoyIaw [url=http://jakkerparkadk.com/] canada goose[/url] DrnOsn DtjTbh http://jakkerparkadk.com/ OayRwj YsxRqt [url=http://canadagoosenorwayhome.com/] canada goose norge[/url] ZvlKan MysRkc http://canadagoosenorwayhome.com/ TruTtv YimOnj [url=http://gooseparkasite.com/]Canada Goose Parka[/url] KedLlj LvuDuq http://gooseparkasite.com/ TsyGsl