Thursday, December 27, 2007

Assassinée

Before we begin shedding too copious tears for the late Benazir Bhutto, we should recall what precisely she represented, which was a megolomaniacal, Western kleptocrat who thought of Pakistan as a family fief and who, in many unguarded moments, spoke of it as such as well. Now I, for one, would prefer to live under a corrupt aristocrat than under a military dictator. That said, all the speculation about how Bhutto's death will affect Pakistan's "transition to democracy" is perfectly crazy.

I admit, though, that the cui bono confuses me a bit.

11 comments:

bdr said...

Why the puzzlement?

Since the US considers itself the center of the universe and ruler of the world, why wouldn't the American media see the assassination of one of America's proxies through the prism of Hillary's electability?

Jean said...

IOZ, you summed it up perfectly. I knew I could count on you.

badri said...

this may be beyond who benefits as seen from this part of the world .
even before she returned really orthodox elements had declared her a target . remember the welcome suicide bombers which killed 100 plus in karachi . to them she is a corrupt westernized WOMAN who also is agent of great satan !
then going by past she did have lots of enemies . i recall reading while back it was her husband who was behind assassination of her brother . so there are also elements of mafia like feud / op .
i really doubt general was behind as he has pretty much out manuevered her and americans .
this is all looking from distance now as i left sub-continent ( indian side ) ages ago .
i do agree a corrupt arristocrat is better than a corrupt general if that is all the choice is .
tariq ali had a good article about her recently in LBR ..
Daughter of the West
Tariq Ali
http://www.lrb.co.uk/v29/n24/ali_01_.html
i

Justin said...

I'd bet that they would be talking about how it affects our upcoming presidential election... Does this help the Hillarities or the Hucksters?

Funny thing during the 06 elections, the media carried on a fair amount about who the Iraqis wanted to win. Finally someone, and I don't remember who, thought to go and ask them. By his account Iraqis didn't care or really have awareness of our domestic political situation, anymore than we care or aware of who runs to be sheriff of Diyala.

I have said before, we look across the Pacific and Atlantic to look at the rest of the world and are only capable of seeing our own reflections staring back.

Marie said...

Because Bhutto was the Rice/Bush plan for bringing "democracy" to Pakistan and secure their legacy as the great American democratizers. Cheney would have preferred just to blow the place up as we did to make the new democracy in Iraq but those nukes scared Condi.

Anonymous said...

Man, I'm sick of trying of us trying to bring democracy to countries that don't want or need it. Remember when it was enough just to get a McDonald's in?

Comandante Agí said...

Today, NPR pre-empted their regular programming to discuss the assassination. The discourse centered on the ever important question - what should WE do? After all, Pakistan is OUR problem. The good ol' USA is responsible to fix/control/manipulate whatever goes on in those parts...

stephanie g said...

Hey, I'm all for gender equality. I think it's funny that so many tropical hellholes have had women in leadership positions over the last fifty years. It just goes to show you that a woman can be as corrupt and authoritarian as any man. And now we get dramatic assassination plots? Awesome. I'm just waiting for some woman leader to be caught in some steamy sexual scandal involving strapping teenage pages. Then things will really be on a "level playing field."

Someone hopes someone will "pull a Bhutto" on Hillary Clinton in 3, 2, 1...

CK said...

Quite probable that the hit was by a local political group. Not one of the ones that is international in scope. A.Q. has supposedly claimed responsibility but then they would either way.

Anonymous said...

As stated, the killing is the rejection by fundamentalism of a feared Western influence. Bhutto and the MICFiC saw each other as allies of convenience.

Nevertheless, I did shed a tear or two - for Benazir and for all the stinking Paki wogs. Oh, the humanity.

May the Creative Forces of the Universe have mercy on our souls, if any.

mistah charley, SB, MA, PhD, JSPS

badri said...

another good article from Tariq ali . he also knew her . so many potential elements including some from govt agencies who could be involved .
he is a life long Trot so " party thingie " is natural for him though it has real potential in the pakistani context

http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/story/0,,2232700,00.html
A tragedy born of military despotism and anarchy

The assassination of Benazir Bhutto heaps despair upon Pakistan. Now her party must be democratically rebuilt

Tariq Ali
Friday December 28, 2007
The Guardian