Thursday, March 06, 2008

The View from the Panopticon

Brazil was more prescient that 1984. It more accurately observed the decrepitude of Dystopia. The weakness of Orwell's work was in his villains, his inner party members who really knew what they were doing. If you haven't seen Gilliam's film, or haven't seen it in a while, pick it up, watch it, and then read this article. Tuttle, Buttle, etc.

I fear a surveillance society not because I think that the government will actually catch me in my subversion, but because I fear that it will think that it's caught me in my subversion. The pressure to "produce results" leads to the issuance of too many traffic tickets. Imagine what it will do when someone has to justify spending a bajillion dollars on some kind of algorithmic AI that's supposed to psychohistorically predict when a new 9/11 will change everything all over again forever. The more I order from Amazon, the kookier its recommendations for me. Entrail-reading isn't science, no matter how much one wishes it were so.

19 comments:

Anonymous said...

I'm heading out to the local Hollywood Video to see if they have "Brazil", and if I can get on that Govt. watchlist.

"I fear a surveillance society not because I think..., but because I fear that it will think that it's caught me in my subversion". (Perversion?)

Truer words were never written.

TT

Montag said...

I love that movie, and I agree with everything you just said.

Any subversive ideas to make ABC release the Max Headroom television series for public consumption? there we saw an equally decrepit Dystopia, foresaw media control of 'the truth,' but best of all foresaw the existence 'blanks,' people who managed to live off the surveillance grid.

Ashley said...

The movie is too painful to watch ever again. I don't see the comedy in it as you are completely correct, the villains and machinations are all too similar. Too much like a really convincing bad dream.

On the other note. Though I notice they are now carrying things like "Fresh Whole Rabbit" which would be my recommendation; if you'd cook for me anyway.

paolaccio said...

"It's going from the horse-and-buggy days to the space age, that's what it's like," said Sgt. Chuck Violette of the Tucson police department, one of almost 1,600 law enforcement agencies that uses a commercial data-mining system called Coplink.

That is the most perfectest self-satirising sentences ever written in any news report evar. "Chuck Violette!" "Coplink!"

Irony just rolled over in its grave and ripped a wicked fart.

Keifus said...

I wonder whether the, um, clients of CopLink are presented with a bill afterwards. (Might be a matter of how you draw up the control volume, that one.)

I'd be more impressed if these algorithmic AIs were more busy finding out mathematical truths. Maybe a way to get around that pesky incompleteness thingie for starters.

K (sorry, it was a recent diversion)

Anonymous said...

a great movie made priceless by robert deniro's brilliant turn. the renegade air conditioner repairman (the one who lives in the reality-based community) -- i love it.

Fledermaus said...

Bingo. The problem with 1984 is that Big Bro exerted an unrealistic amount of control over the citizens. As Robert Anton Wilson could have told Orwell, the first problem with command and control systems is that the people making decisions will not recieve accurate information - instead they will hear what they want to hear. And every single person wants to hear what a good job they are doing.

"We're all in it together"

Anonymous said...

Quibble: I don't think Orwell ever meant to imply that everyone swept up by the Thought Police was a genuine subversive. Remember Parsons?

Even now, if you try and pin down your basic plain vanilla Guantanamo fan on narrow matters like accuracy and efficiency, it doesn't take long to find out that those are really pretty peripheral to the central goal -- rounding up ragheads and fellow travelers, lots of them.

Suspicion breeds confidence, right?
-- sglover

IOZ said...

I don't think I implied that everyone picked up by the thought police was. The thought police did, however, have a reason for picking up people like Parsons, and you should remember that by the logic of O'Brien, Parsons was in fact a subversive. The internal consistency of The Party is precisely its inaccuracy as prophecy or observation.

Steve Muhlberger said...

1984: a brilliant book that could never be made into a good movie.

Brazil: a brilliant cinematic do-over, updated as appropriate.

Did someone say Brazil was a comedy? Dark, dark glasses.

TGGP said...

Isaac Asimov fills in for Anton Wilson on Orwell here.

I've never seen Brazil in any video store. Wasn't it a dud or something?

Anonymous said...

steve: Janet Maslin in the Times: "...a superb example of the power of comedy to underscore serious ideas...."

tggp: Best Screenplay - Tom Stoppard, Terry Gilliam - 1985 L.A. Film Critics; Best Director - Terry Gilliam (same); Best Film - (same). Multiple Academy nominations for Screenplay and Art Direction.

You're right: the local video store (a 20 minute further drive on my carbon footprint now that the local Blockbuster went bellyup) didn't have it. Fortunately I had other errands in that town, did the all-right-turns thang, etc. Anything to help our kids' future, right?!

Anonymous said...

I don't think I implied that everyone picked up by the thought police was.

Aw, I just wanted to do some knee-jerk hairsplitting. The weekend's coming up, after all....
-- sglover

Fledermaus said...

Isaac Asimov fills in for Anton Wilson on Orwell here.

That was really interesting I like the way Issac gets to the true horror of 1984"

"part of the horror of his picture of 1984 is his eloquent description of the low quality of the gin and tobacco."

Anonymous said...

you can get a 3cd version of it - 1 disc is the director's cut, another full of extra stuff, the 3rd a "love conquers all" happy ending version

--hermitlobster

p.s. speaking of rabbit the original version of chicken cacciatore was rabbit cacciatore - years ago i would make it from frozen rabbit i got at the supermarket - the brand name was Pel-Freez [referring to the dual use of fur and meat, no doubt] - www.pelfreez-bio.com has a lot of rabbit products available - gamma globulin, thymus acetone powder, etc.

Anonymous said...

more on the history of mass nurture and harvesting of rabbits:

Our History

The history of Pel-Freez began humbly in Englewood California in 1911. A pregnant rabbit named Betsy Ann was given to the son of Herman Pelphrey, a local resident. The rabbits born to Betsy Ann grew, bred, and eventually the back yard of the Pelphrey’s home was overrun with rabbits. In time, Herman would turn the dilemma into an opportunity.

He first sold fresh rabbit meat to his neighbors. When the demand proved to be sustainable, he set his goals higher. By 1918 he was marketing the meat to the public under the name of the “H.F. Pelphrey Company.” Operations continued unchanged until 1936 when the firm began to explore the production and marketing of frozen rabbit meat. Delayed by the advent of World War II, the marketing of frozen rabbit meat didn’t become a reality until 1947 when the “Pel-Freez” name was developed to emphasize the “frozen” meat. Around that time, Robert Dubbell married into the Pelphrey family. Robert would play a pivotal role in establishing Pel-Freez operations in Rogers, Arkansas, as well as entering other markets for rabbit by-products.

The business remains with the Dubbell family to this day with Robert’s son, David Dubbell, being the current owner. Pel-Freez is currently the largest rabbit meat processor in the United States and is also well known for producing high quality research raw materials. These high quality raw materials from a broad range of animal species are used globally in the development of in-vitro diagnostic kits, drug discovery, vaccines, HLA typing, and more in the biotechnology research and diagnostic markets. Pel-Freez Arkansas, LLC continues to strive to produce high quality products, while providing excellent customer service.

You can’t put a price on great customer service. At Pel-Freez, it’s free!

paolaccio said...

Coniglio Cacciatore

1 ½ tbsp Rosemary dried
¾ tbsp chilli flakes
1 tbsp Black pepper coarsely ground
¾ tbsp Oregano dried
3 Celery stalks cut into strips
3 Carrots peeled and cut in strips
1 ½ tbsp Sage dried
4 lb rabbit
2+ Shallots chopped rough
10 Olives roughly chopped
5 or 6 Large crepini mushrooms cut in quarters
6 cloves Garlic chopped
3 tbsp Extra Virgin olive oil (Optional)
Canned Plum tomatoes for cacciatore (600g) (adjust ingredients for additional volume of approx 20-25%
1+ cup Dry red wine (240 ml)

Preheat oven to 350F

§ Cut rabbit into serving pieces – 4 legs +. rub rabbit with ½ the spices

§ Put olive oil in a roasting pan with garlic & salt and ½ the spices. Fry on stove top until transparent (5 min)

§ Add rabbit. Put back & belly pieces in first. Then after they have started to brown add the legs. Cook turning rabbit pieces until browned lightly on all sides (10 - 15 min). Add the wine slowly as rabbit browns to deglaze pan.

§ Add vegetables (celery & carrots & olives & mushrooms)

§ Roast in covered pan until tender (about 60 min). Baste frequently and turn over occasionally. Add rest of wine as needed with basting juices.

§ (if doing cacciatore add tomatoes and all the wine at this point)

§ Remove rabbit and keep warm at 225F

§ Place on high heat on stove top to reduce. Pour sauce over rabbit.

Serves 4.

Anonymous said...

After watching "Brazil" and feeling vaguely uncomfortable, go see "Children of Men" for some clarity- this is how its going to be.

TGGP said...

The antinatalist blog discussed Children of Men here.