It appears that Chris Matthews, the prolix terrier behind the desk of the pornographically titled Hardball, said that John McCain is "kind of a Martin Luther." Oh, you mean he's a zealot and an anti-Semite? Yes? No?
Martin Luther looked at the gorgeous absurdity that was Renaissance Catholicism and thought to himself, "You know, what this really needs is an injection of dourness," and then he set about trying to out-Ferdinand Ferdinand on the question of the Jews. I am firmly convinced that had their never been a Reformation, we would have attained to a glorious, renewed Paganism centuries ago. Plenary indulgences, for instance, were positively Babylonian. High theater became the dull meeting house, and all the pomp and faggotry of men in costume and boy choirs and incense and trilled Latin Rs faded into bad congregational hymning. Yes, it is true that we got Bach out of the deal, but we also got John Calvin, who haunts America in particular to this day.
Personally, I'd describe John McCain as a kind of wannabe Tamerlane.
Monday, June 30, 2008
John McFlames
Labels:
John McCain,
The Media
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
6 comments:
Perhaps it's a comment about McCane's embracing of all ne fancy technological gizmos like movable type.
There's a scene in The Tudors 2nd Season where Thomas Cromwell walks into a room with a fellow Protestant reformer from the court. "What is it?" says his comrade when he sees a big wooden thingamajig.
"That is a printing press."
Nietzsche held a similar view of the German Reformation. Purity is a destructive concept when introduced on a societal scale. And the corruption of the Catholic church was probably a good force for Europe; Protestantism gave way immediately to tribalism. Of course, maybe the latter just used to former.
Either way, this reminds me of all the times I've heard people speak of a "Muslim Martin Luther." Good lord, they don't even know the history they would export.
Excellent!
A Muslim Martin Luther? Shit, with the Sunni/Shi'a split, they're still screwing around with Arius, Pelagius and Zororaster.
If you accept the whole Christian God thing, Luther makes more sense than if you don't. The was a discussion in academic circles as to whether or not he was the first modern man, the first existentialist, or the last true medievalist.
Actually, he was an anarchist until he was in charge. He stopped worrying about consistency of practice and went fairly far away from where he seemed to be headed philosophically when he published the Theses. It helps the myth that the clowns he was opposed to like Johann Tetzel were like that guy selling various hunks of crap for 19.95 but call right now, and we'll double your order. Tetzel's sermon from Osborne's Luther, as I recall, was actually a translation of one of his Falwellesque rants. Of course, from Tetzel's nonsense the world got St Peter's and the money for Michelangelo.
Luther was OK on the Juze at foist, basically until the late 1530s. Then something went very wrong, and if you look at his "table-talks" it seems to have been a run-in with a quack doctor. I guess our boy Marty was kinda fond of the medical treatment, if you know what I mean, which makes sense if you realize that what they usually gave you had a shitload of opium in it.
Anyhoo, Airman McCoonie had better have a medical fetish at his age. Call the old boy a Luther's Luther. As for the whole changing the course of Western Civilization stuff, maybe not, but I bet he could convince Pepperdine to alter their Western Civ curriculum, which is the next best thing.
Post a Comment