High Despoiler of Donkdom Michael J. Smith puts me in mind again of the good old Wystan Hugh. I recall arguing with someone once, à propos Monsieur le président Buisson, that any proposition holding electoral success as a mark of or evidence for superior intelligence was inherently false, the the skill sets, as we call 'em around the office, necessary to actuate officeholderdom were unrelated to keen intellect and were linked instead to a fulsome sense of ethical abandon. Whither the conviction that all politicians are crooks and morons? Folk wisdom, but wisdom nonetheless, that.
Anyway, mutatis mutandis, Obama and the gang. The Lib conviction that once his own comrades effaced bias from the halls of Washington and imposed scientific governance, every problem could be solved like textbook physics, i.e., acted on by simple forces, untroubled in their smooth parabolic paths by air resistance, wind, surface mechanics. Amateurs. Half-assed Keynesianism will find its defenders in those who pledge faith and fealty to the Soul-Consuming Elder God of The Something that Must Be Done, who apply a know-nothing acceptance of the doctrine that spending can stimulate growth to arguing that any spending must stimulate growth, a radically different notion when you consider it for just a moment. Other than random appeals to multiplier effects and other such Magiks, no one can quite name a mechanism through which any of the supposed stimuli will stimulate anything. How will any of this money move out into the "broader economy." Motherfuckers don't need more credit; motherfuckers need jobs. I would have less trouble with some new WPA, but the laid-off (and soon-to-be) workforce isn't a manufacturing workforce easily reassigned to construction and infrastructure projects. Take a gander around the office, ye Blogreaders. If yours is anything like mine, the closest thing to shovel-ready is the bag of Tostitos in the kitchenette.
Wednesday, February 11, 2009
The World Is Too Much With Us
Labels:
Economy,
Obama,
the Donkle
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
23 comments:
You're missing the bigger picture. A new People's Labor and Freedom Force will not only put people to work, it will force... er... free the fatties to get in shape, thus reducing the strain on the health care system. Win win!
I just don't see the point of work in general, and even I know how things work and how to make them work. Agents of Change that come into this place usually last for a year or two before heading to some DEP or non-profit where they direct some new regurgitation of an old program of some sort.
AoC: I've taken a position at the DEP promoting Low Impact Development!
Mr.Fun: yeah, that's great. what will you do?
AoC: I'll go to charettes and interject meaningless pathos and inane criticism into the process. like, you know, the developer should consider where the best soils are before laying out his site plan.
Mr.Fun: I don't care if the developer sacrifices little kittens/children on his site. I'm still waiting for AutoCAD and Land Desktop to write the algorithm that will do all of these things for us, and eliminate humans from the process altogether. then I can go home.
AoC: Oh.
Mr.Fun: have fun affecting Change or whatever. idiot.
The best laid delusions of mice and men...
I know my fat ass isn't ready to pick up a jackhammer.
But I can supervise!
"[T]he laid-off (and soon-to-be) workforce isn't a manufacturing workforce easily reassigned to construction and infrastructure projects."
maybe you could work on wind power. that's kinda brainy.
"any spending must stimulate growth"
Didn't Keynes once advocate building pyramids, or diggings holes in the desert or something?
Not that he thought it was the best of possible uses of the money, but that it would increase demand and thus restart the economy in the depression.
Also, Dean Baker here tells us that ANY spending IS in fact stimulus.
http://www.prospect.org/csnc/blogs/beat_the_press_archive?month=02&year=2009&base_name=npr_talks_to_senators_who_comp
Yep, we's all on the cusp of a major dry butt-fuckin' an' they's no way to git ready.
Anonymous 12:42 said...
"I know my fat ass isn't ready to pick up a jackhammer.
But I can supervise!"
And I, my good man, can write the necessary Grant Applications to receive the Mana from Obama!
Anonymous 12:42 said...
"I know my fat ass isn't ready to pick up a jackhammer.
But I can supervise!"
And I, my good man, can write the necessary Grant Applications to receive the Mana from Obama!
I have thought for some time that to become part of the ruling class isn’t so much a matter of brains but a matter of having a certain lack of any morals, a willingness to kiss ass and learning a few tricks rather than an excess of brains. I also agree that what are needed are jobs as in bringing manufacturing back to these shores. I don’t think that is going to happen, I don’t even know how it could happen. It certainly won’t happen with this so-called stimulus package.
All the little household gods
Have started crying, but say
Good-bye now, and put to sea.
--W.H. Auden
Take a gander around the office, ye Blogreaders...
And I'll see... what? People who already have jobs? Maybe the ones who don't have jobs are in better shape, and more willing to try weatherizing a few houses.
I'm not sure I want some unemployed accountant or "account manager" or "Director of Compliance" or sales drone at Circuit City anywhere near a nail gun or flammable anything.
Which means, as our own hypocrisies help destroy their country even more, that the stimulus package may actually do nothing more than stimulate the construction of sweet retirement villas in rural Michoacan.
I'd quote Bob Black on your crude workism, except that I've forgotten all his good lines. It would have been very cutting if I had though.
I'm not sure I want some unemployed accountant or "account manager" or "Director of Compliance" or sales drone at Circuit City anywhere near a nail gun or flammable anything.
Let's see... wasn't there a major sector of the economy that just suffered a huge downturn recently, resulting in hundreds of thousands of lost jobs? I can't remember exactly what those folks were up to, but I think it involved an exotic form of financing called a "mortgage."
SteveB: I'm thinking what Brian meant was that the Venn diagram for the skill-sets of amortization and weatherization is gonna look pretty much like a Hooters T-shirt...
Stimulus spending always extended my growth...
...stimulate the construction of sweet retirement villas in rural Michoacan.
Nonsense! The makers of private jets, real estate agents in Cabo and Fabergé egg salesmen are all counting on this stimulus.
God forbid I show anything around her that'll be perceived as weakness, but I actually think more people in America would engage in manual labor, were it compensated for. I change my mind a lot on this, but I don't think too much of Cubicled America is happy with their increasing infantilism. I'm no utopian, but I think that Americans' disdain for physical work is due to a very realistic assessment of the incentives provided, rather than some innate desire to do nothing and grow ill, pale, and fat.
dude, like Office Space, QED.
I prefer to be engaged at work, it makes the day go by faster. thus I blog. if I'ma sit around all damn day ruining my posture, bored out of my skull, I might as well try and entertain myself. it's just, I look at the work I'm given, and I wind up staring off into space, zoning out, with a drop of drool forming at the crease of my mouth.
and I've long ago ceased believing the grass is greener anywhere else, though every once in a while. . .nah, nevermind. you need to understand that this is a discipline.
I'm not sure I'm refuting your point, btw. mostly just talking nonsense.
I would say that the opportunity to break from this cycle is already there, if one were to realize it. you can make decent cash as a rodman on a survey crew, and all you need to be able to do is read a tape measure, balance a survey rod and stand on your feet for hours. if we were to provide further incentives to go that route, than I say yes, you'd see some changes. just because you see this though doesn't make you special. it's not revelatory that you think that we can be doing something better. I'm not convinced better exists.
I'm saying that even this slothen Cube existence is a form of labor, even if the end results (ie. fat dumb unable to touch their toes Americans) do not comport to your standards for labor. just because it makes us fat and infantile doesn't mean we're not working hard at it, or maintaining some semblance of discipline. sure we could have a million man CCC in each state with lots of fit Americans who work their bodies and are able to maintain a life of the mind while lost in physical labor. that'd be great, I guess. I don't think we'd be any happier being fit and able bodied.
I have to get up, my piriformis is acting up again.
I never said it wasn't labor. I tried to preface it with "manual" and "physical," all that. But you are right--there are several examples of properly compensated, more physical labor. I know a bunch of people who work baggage at an airport. They're happy.
No, I won't say what labor "ought" to be. I just believe (assume, figure, say, have a hunch that, etc) that a lot of people bought into the education lie, and now they're neither compensated nor respected nor happy, but I think they'd give a lot of other work a try if they could get it and believed that it would pay as much or pay better. I don't believe in the inherent quality of any work. I just don't dismiss Americans' willingness to do manual labor off-hand.
But to repeat, I agree with your argument regarding people working hard at work that's making them fat and infantile. RSI and bad knees may just be the modern man's black lung. Don't think me a moralist; I don't hate Americans for their weight and their illness. Hell, I see how hard all my friends in the cubes work. But I also know they're willing to do other things, too.
I'm not sure I want some unemployed accountant or "account manager" or "Director of Compliance" or sales drone at Circuit City anywhere near a nail gun or flammable anything.
C'mon, that situation may increase demand for, and pressure for the reform of, medical services.
Motherfuckers don't need more credit; motherfuckers need jobs.
Although this may be true, it's facile. [This is because sometimes the truth is facile. No offense intended.]*
What mofus really need is mos to fu.
* Sometimes the truth is not facile. These things happen.
Post a Comment