Well, yesterday's kiddos were about a jillion times more compelling than today's grab-bag affair. "This is what democracy looks like!" Is it? Yoy, I'll take the global gulag. A most undignified afternoon all around. I hopped on the trusty Trek hybrid and dogged this sorry accretion of has-been and never-was political yuksterism.
Personally, I think the whole global order is close enough to an inflection point that I reasonably expect to see some or other revolution of affairs within my lifetime. As to what I can do to bring it about or speed it along at least, I'm fairly convinced: not a thing. Nor do I share anyone's certainty that what comes next must inevitably be better. Even were I to believe that peoplepower could crack the foundations on which rests the superstructure of global capital, I am . . . dubious of the papier mâché revolution.
Friday, September 25, 2009
Signs and Banners of the Future
Labels:
G20,
Protest,
Revolutions
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
33 comments:
Oh noes, Ioz! This way lies lesser of two evilisms!
Yeah, but there's gotta be some room between total fucking surrender and having neither the desire nor ability to "bring about the revolution," right? Or, maybe this defeatism is just a pose because the "superstructure of global capital" isn't treating you too bad these days.
They also serve who only stand and mock.
When your blood's running in the streets, blog commenter SteveB, do let us know.
Whom do you suppose you serve in having and arguing for your beliefs?
a subtle re-statement of principles brings...a re-hashing of the arguments for action.
As to what I can do to bring it about or speed it along at least, I'm fairly convinced: not a thing. Nor do I share anyone's certainty that what comes next must inevitably be better.
OK, so people protesting at the G20 believe that "what comes next" will inevitably be better, and their only job is to speed things along.
Here's an alternative theory: They don't know what comes next, may even think what comes next is likely to be worse, and, for those very reasons, are trying to influence what comes next.
I like to think IOZ contributes plenty -- often more.
HEADLINE!
IOZ In Skepticism Shocker!
JRB- here here
"IOZ is just a buddy helping his buddies out."
The above is the most noble thing I think anyone can aspire to
Yeah, but there's gotta be some room between total fucking surrender and having neither the desire nor ability to "bring about the revolution," right?
Haha. Blawg!
Nor do I share anyone's certainty that what comes next must inevitably be better.
fuck armageddon, this is hell
the first two lines of that tune take on a second meaning after the last few days here in the WIIOZ? comments. "there's people out there that say I'm no good, 'cause I don't believe the things that I should..."
have a good weekend, monsieur, you've earned it.
I'm very much in sympathy with SteveB's "alternative theory," which is I think is a fine criticism, and closer to my own view.
But I'm sure IOZ appreciates the question: why is it so important what he thinks?
Has there been a lifetime in which a revolution hasn't happened in the past, I dunno, few hundred years?
Has there been a lifetime in which a revolution hasn't happened in the past, I dunno, few hundred years?
Jon Benet's?
I thought about a hybrid, but I went for the road bike.
I have to admit that I took part in the direct action shutting down the streets around the convention center during the WTO Seattle protests and remain proud of it, but even at the time was pretty annoyed by the "This is what democracy looks like" chant. I kept thinking, "democracy looks like riot cops and clouds of tear gas? What?"
Yo Agi - the hybrid is a commuter vehicle. Takes the potholes better, and you can't beat it on dem hillz in da burgh. Plus you can't dent the steel frame with a garbage truck. Wouldn't recommend it for serious riding, though. It's a tank.
IOz,
Your resignation into acerbic and literate cynical indifference is indeed an inspiration. The barricades can wait for one last beer.
Thanks!
I was nodding along until I came to "superstructure," which is a very silly word.
Meh. Who gives a shit? Was the point, yo.
But I'm sure IOZ appreciates the question: why is it so important what he thinks?
If he thinks it's important enough to write it here and enable comments, we think it's important enough to respond. Seems like a straight-up exchange. What's the problem? Fanboys don't like it when their hero gets criticized?
Couldn't you have dovetailed this in with your newest Whole Foods recipe?
Why not sit back? The revolution will be televised. In fact, I think they'll do it as a reality show starring Tori Spelling, Gary Coleman and Eliot Spitzer.
Ioz, you really should look at this: http://leninology.blogspot.com/2009/09/g20-protests.html
Where are these people coming from? You keep a fairly high level of discourse on here usually, but the people on here defending the patchouli and violence crowd are really annoying.
If you want to read a blog that really supports and get behind drunk crustie punks and talks about Anarchy and Direct Action and Guerrilla Bicycling then read such a blog. What did you expect to find here.
They don't know what comes next, may even think what comes next is likely to be worse, and, for those very reasons, are trying to influence what comes next.
How are they trying to influence things?
Never mind. I realize that in The Land of Steverino, commenting at IOZ's blog constitutes real meaningful efforts at change. Yea, though he walks through the vales and draws of an un-homogenized land full of teabaggers and Rethugs, Steverino is emboldened by his superior liberalist mindset and approach!
Vive le gradschool-trained sense of superiority! Drive a Prius, change the world!
How are they trying to influence things?
Well, using whatever means they can think of. Lots of talk about what's wrong with the world, trying to imagine some alternatives, trying to create those alternatives where the world gives you an opening. Plus some attempts at mass protest. Which, I'll admit, doesn't seem to be very effective.
Worse than ineffective. Self-medicating.
Yes, self-medicating. And, as with other forms of self-medication, let's not be puritans about it.
Ha.
I think there's an anti-capitalism big enough for all of us.
Protest is so passé.
When the anti-capitalist inflection point comes, can the libertards have new hampshire? If its not too much to ask, because, no disrespect, fuck egalitarianism
When a bunch of ninnies thought Y2K would bring the End Of The World As We Know It they actually bought fallout shelters with jugs of water and canned food. Is IOZ actually putting his money where his mouth is? I think there is much ruin in a nation, and it will all keep shambling along longer than me (assuming we don't all turn into immortal space robots), but I may end up in a bunker in Wyoming merely because hell is other people.
Post a Comment