Wednesday, September 30, 2009

That Which Is True of Our Ideas of Things Must Be True of the Things Themselves

Accordingly, a large proportion of the erroneous thinking which exists in the world proceeds upon a tacit assumption, that the same order must obtain among the objects in nature which obtains among our ideas of them. That if we always think of two things together, the two things must always exist together. That if one thing makes us think of another as preceding or following it, that other must precede it or follow it in actual fact. And conversely, that when we cannot conceive two things together they cannot exist together and that their combination may, without further evidence, be rejected from the list of possible occurrences.

-John Stuart Mill
Here is an interesting exercise in a priori from the New York Times op-ed page. Because the recently revealed nuclear facility at Qom, Iran makes no sense as a nuclear-bomb-making facility, it must be a part of a diversified bomb-making program. Yes, this is the sort of Jesuitical logic that makes the Times America's leading publication.

13 comments:

Anonymous said...

Well, you know, where's there's smoke, there's a molotov cocktail.

fish said...

Good to see the Times go to level headed, reputable sources:

Gary Milhollin is director of the Wisconsin Project on Nuclear Arms Control.[1] He publishes Iran Watch, an online clearinghouse for articles about Iran. Previously, he published Iraqwatch, which was dedicated to "tracking weapons of mass destruction in Iraq." He has written articles for numerous newspapers including the Wall Street Journal and New York Times, and has given testimonies to the House Committees on International Relations, National Security, and Armed Services.[2][3]
Among his editorials in the Wall Street Journal, Gary Milhollin had accused Hans Blix, chief weapons inspector in Iraq, of being "timid"[4] and "irrelevant"[5] for failing to locate weapons of mass destruction in Iraq.

Enron said...

I mean, it's not as if the United States has a diversified nuclear bomb making program.

a dead iraqi is an insurgent said...

"My god, there's nothing in this house but a rusty old shotgun barrel -- that's incontrovertible evidence of the presence of a million machine guns!"

hv said...

Team B, anyone?

..."Team B" group that insisted that all of the CIA's intelligence about the Soviet Union's declining economy, its military weakness and its genuine desire to reach a new, peaceful accommodation to the West while reforming its own system was all false; Rumsfeld and his cohorts insisted -- on the basis of false evidence, manipulated evidence and no evidence at all -- that the "evil empire" was developing a whole range of new super-weapons that would be able to destroy the United States at a moment's notice. The fact that the CIA, the NSA, the DIA and the whole phalanx of America's intelligence services couldn't find any evidence for these weapons of mass destruction only proved how devious the Russians were in cloaking them.

Anonymous said...

Is Hegel offended?

Anonymous said...

Well they waited for the fall before rolling out the new product.

mustachios of understanding said...

"How did you determine that Mr. Smith was the killer, detective?"

"Well, we searched his home, and we didn't find the murder weapon. Need I say more, gentlemen?"

SteveB said...

If Iran built a second plant of the same size as the Qum operation and ran them in tandem, the production times described above could be almost halved.

That's some high-level mathematical thinkin', right there.

And if Iran had some eggs, they could have ham and eggs. If they had some ham.

zencomix said...

You know, I myself dabbled in a priori. Not in the Qum, of course.

wavydavy said...

SteveB --

I would have gone with "And if pigs had wings, they could fly."

I like yours better.

Dan said...

I like the old, "If things were different, they wouldn't be the same," myself.

mds said...

Gary Milhollin is director of the Wisconsin Project on Nuclear Arms Control.

Oh, yes, I'll bet he's a real champion of global nuclear disarmament.

And if Iran had some eggs, they could have ham and eggs. If they had some ham.

And if ham were halal.