Wednesday, April 21, 2010

Decadence

There is an ingeniously specious logic to the proposition that the failure to prevent a wrong abnegates the duty to redress it. That said, the defenders of speculation have become amusingly untethered from the typical and traditional defense of investment banking and market capitalism, which is to say that it these are the mechanisms through which the capitalist economy apportions capital to new and productive enterprise. It is perhaps the most fundamental defense of market capitalism--that it is a system uniquely effective at raising money to fund production--and it goes totally unmentioned. From the President to the pages of the Washington Post, you'll hear a lot of talk about the so-called financial industry, but no talk about industry. Whether Goldman Sachs and its peer organizations broke any particular laws or committed any particular fraud is almost wholly beside the point. Far more germane and far more damning is that they exist in a purely speculative and entirely fictive parallel economy in which no productive activity takes place. I mean, at least Wal-Mart sells some shit.

17 comments:

la Rana said...

They create wealth! Its all very complicated and I suppose a rube like you just wouldn't understand.

Dan said...

Were this a facebook status update, I would "like" it, yo.

periscopedepth said...

I'm... I'm... I'm just a grifter, Tom. I'm... I'm... I'm... I'm... I'm an nobody! But I'll tell you what, I never crossed a friend, Tom. I never killed anybody, I never crossed a friend, nor you, I'll bet. We're not like those animals! This is not us! Th... th... this is some hop dream! It's a dream, Tommy! I'm praying to you! I can't die! I can't die... out here in the woods, like a dumb animal! In the woods, LIKE A DUMB ANIMAL! Like a dumb animal! I can't... I can't... I CAN'T DIE OUT HERE IN THE WOODS!... like a dumb animal. I can't... die!

Anonymous said...

I don't know man, I was just on a deal where Goldman lined up $500,000,000 in bond funds for a coal company. I mean, it doesn't get much more industrial than coal.

Jess said...

The main problem with the WaPo column is that it counters the SEC's allegedly poorly-sourced narrative with... a slightly different narrative, pulled out of the columnist's ass. It becomes difficult to credit anything else in the column. If employees or agents of Goldman lied to a Goldman customer about a deal, it seems reasonable to hold Goldman accountable for that, if you can prove it.

But yeah, of course, a sale requires a buyer and a seller. I'm not surprised that no one in public office will admit that. For them, finance stopped being about resource allocation when it became a morality play. Losing money on a bad investment, whether that's a McMansion or a CDO, is not about good and evil. As Taleb says, evolution does not teach by convincing, but by destroying.

Anonymous said...

bingo! the financial sector exists on an entirely different economic plane, having no interaction at all with the "economy" of most americans' lives. while some see this as problematic, others notice how much fucking money you can make without doing any work, and jump on board.

Enron said...

If only I could make as much money playing Mafia Wars.

fledermaus said...

It was bad enough when they used annual debt restructuring to skim another few million from the corporate coffers. But now they've found a way to make money on bad loans. Subprime was just the beginning, there's still subprime muni bonds, and commercial real estate.

Anonymous said...

Will Wilkinson is sooo hard right now.

Anonymous said...

Even more important than sellin' shit is makin' shit.

Jess said...

Will, stop posting anonymously, and stop talking about yourself in the third person.

Anonymous said...

Bored with politics, econ, "religion." How 'bout some "Culture" tags, bruh? A movie or book list. Say "the inimitable Coetzee" again. Mock a blockbuster. What's on yer Pandora? Also, manecdotes with cute French banter.

Come on.

Soj said...

Wait a damn minute, I thought the deal with Bretton Woods was the USA finances the REST of the world's economic productivity, "occasionally" using force to en-force the rules and the rest of the time kicks back and watches those checks roll in. Where did it go wrong? *sadface*

Rowan said...

In Which IOZ Discovers That Finance Is Like, Totally Just People Playing With Money And Shit

Tune in next week, for IOZ Compares High Finance To A Legal Poker Game Subsidized By The Government

davidly said...

Bob Dole has a 15 percent erection! With a poophole for capital gains, of course.

Anonymous said...

Rowan: Yup, and yup. You mean to imply that the good Monsieur oversimplifies, or that he is late in having had these epiphanies?

Rowan said...

He's probably not late in having the epiphanies. Seems like a pretty clever dude and all. But he's writing like he is.