Sunday, August 01, 2010

Waste. Want.

To this day, my grandfather insists on eating every bit of food on his plate, no matter how terrible it may be, no matter how full he already is, "because there are children starving in China," and while I doubt any practical effect, as a minor matter of personal morality, I've always found it admirable, this rather frail old man tucking into the last two bites of chicken, though his stomach protests, because it is a sin for those blessed with plenty to waste it in a world where some have so much less. Anyway, here is a photograph from the New York Times of the Australian government destroying perfectly good shoes because they are "counterfeit".



If ever there were a demonstration of the inhuman fraud perpetrated by the defenders of so-called intellectual property, this is it. And while I do not harbor any illusion that the world's poor can be dressed entirely in fake Vuitton, the fact that truckloads of perfectly good shoes would be destroyed--destroyed!--because they violate some absurd copyright should sicken any decent human being. If ever there were an image defining a decadent, wasteful society on a self-imposed slide toward an orgy of gratuitous doom, this is it.

35 comments:

Anonymous said...

When I was a kid my grandpa indoctrinated me into the Clean Plate Club, "because their are kids starving in China."

KCinDC said...

Reminds me of the people dumping kerosene on oranges in "The Grapes of Wrath".

Anonymous said...

Newsreels in the 30's famously showed the dumping of milk in the midst of starvation...now we have this farce.

Patents = state sponsored protection racket

Huntly said...

What is it that you are most upset by, the lost income that could have been generated from the sale of the shoes or that they couldn't have been diverted and given to people who don't have shoes? I have images of children in rural China/Africa walking through the crops in high heels! I am no fan of intellectual property but unless there is money to be made from them no one is going to make them.

girard said...

What is it that you are most upset by

I think the targets of this excellent post were as follows:

1. The idea that there are real shoes and fakes based on copyrighted brands and designs that don't make the shoes more usable.

2. That the Australian government destroyed the knock-offs rather than giving them to folks who could use them.

It's true that shoes with a super-high markup based on the transcendental qualities imparted by brand names and athlete endorsements would not get made if no one bought them and by extension knock-offs would not get made either. But I don't see any particular merit in that as a response to this post. What's your point exactly?

Think of the Chilblains said...

It's a goddamn sin, IOZ, but the greater evil has been averted - those pumps really clashed with the dump truck.

Leonard said...

Of course there is value in real Vuitton: snob appeal. It is a credit to our society that we have the luxury to pay good money for prestigious vapor. That the state makes this possible with its intellectual property laws: meh. That it is a waste of resources: meh again. The amount of resources expended on the creation of copycat shoes is trivial compared to, say, the amount of resources poured into war. (Not to mention the killin'.) Or the destruction caused by paying people to be indolent. Fake shoes are just shoes. Paying someone to do nothing destroys the meaning in their life. A destroyed life is a worse thing than some destroyed leather.

I think the real point here is what girard said: absent the IP laws, those shoes would not exist. So this is not really a travesty to compare to so many other forms of state destructiveness. It's just a normal, garden-variety state fuckup.

George Jones said...

Speaking of our late date, this little bit from a recent LRB piece on the oil "blowout" in the Gulf struck me as achingly apt:

'When I visited a La. Parish Work Release jail this past Friday, it was early evening, and the inmates were returning from their 12-hour workday shovelling oil-soaked sand into trash bags,’ my friend Abe Louise Young, whom I met through her Katrina oral history project nearly five years ago, wrote to me in early July.

'Wearing BP uniforms and rubber boots (nothing identifying them as inmates), they were driven in an unmarked white van, and looked dog-tired. The majority of beach workers are African-American. It’s a striking sight in the Louisiana coastal towns where eight out of ten people are white – and the only tell-tale sign of their incarceration. In the first few days after the blowout, clean-up workers could be seen wearing scarlet pants and white T-shirts with ‘Inmate Labor’ printed in large red block letters. Outrage flared among local officials and newly unemployed residents desperate for work. Those explicit outfits disappeared in a matter of days. The clothing change is no accident – it’s an effort at concealing the nature of BP’s labour force. Work-release prisoners have no choice in their job assignments. After arriving in BP uniforms, the inmates suit up in Tyvek head-to-toe coveralls.'


Who needs the gulag?

Captain Spaulding said...

For an image defining a decadent, wasteful society on a self-imposed slide toward an orgy of gratuitous doom, I would have gone with the fact that someone can be arrested for going to the trouble of diving into a dumpster to "steal" goods (even food!) that would otherwise end up in a landfill.

No Moron said...

Practical suggestion for items violating IP laws that are confiscated and that have use value: Destroy the non-use, IP value and preserve the use value, then offer the items to the poor or to any charitable organization that is willing to distribute them and transport them to where the items use value can be consumed.

Anonymous said...

There are kids in China who could perfectly well eat those shoes.

Anonymous said...

I recently represented one half of a father-son duo who were charged with multiple counts of selling counterfeit goods and threatened with 30 years in jail. Though they got much less than that, it was all especially stupid because some of their best customers were the very jailers, police officers, court workers, etc. who would later hound them.

And, in spite of the judge's order, the police agency is refusing to donate the clothes and insists on destroying it.

Cüneyt said...

I congratulate Leonard on shoehorning a bash of welfare to his remarks on the waste of the state. Paying people to be indolent, huh? Sounds like business to me.

Anonymous said...

I'd rather pay people to sit at home and jerk off than get a "real" job shuffling around papers and gambling with gargantuan sums of imaginary money. I'm sentimental like that.

b-psycho said...

Matty trying to get on your good side or something?

Anonymous said...

KCinDC: same thought occurred to me as well.

Montag said...

always so much hate for the idlers. dag.

Paying someone to do nothing destroys the meaning in their life.

if what i do to make a living is what gives my life meaning, fucking shoot me now. i lay awake at night scared that when i go they will say, "he was an excellent Detailer," or, "he was a good worker: never called in sick." fuck me.

i kind of admire the guy who rides the welfare rolls all summer, doing the occasional odd job, getting paid under the table, then calculates what he has to get hemmed up for to get tossed in jail just over the winter months. wouldn't care to live like that myself, but i do admire it in a way. don't tell my brother-in-law i said that. fuck, i'd never hear the end of it.

Leonard said...

Your revolution is over, Mr. Anonymous. Condolences. The bums lost. My advice is to do what your parents did: get a job, sir. The bums will always lose. Do you hear me, Anonymous?

Duane Harkness said...

I share your sentiment IOZ. In my opinion, this is a perfect example of mottainai. Wikipedia has a good article on the concept.

Candy said...

Leonard: What jobs would those be, exactly?

Anonymous said...

Ahaa, itѕ рleаѕant conversation rеgarding this piecе of
writіng here аt this website, I have read all that, sο
now me аlѕo commenting at this plаce.
My web site ... loans for bad credit

Anonymous said...

Ηi there, just becamе aware of your blog thrοugh Google,
and found thаt it's truly informative. I'm going to watch out
for brusselѕ. ӏ'll appreciate if you continue this in future. Numerous people will be benefited from your writing. Cheers!
Look at my weblog ; how to stop snoring

Anonymous said...

Ӏt's amazing to pay a visit this web site and reading the views of all friends regarding this piece of writing, while I am also zealous of getting experience.
my webpage - pay day loans

Anonymous said...

I have learn sеveral excellent stuff hеre. Definitely
price bоοkmаrking for гevisiting.
I surprise hοω sο muсh attempt
you ѕеt to make such a magnifісent informatiνe ωeb sіtе.
Stop by my blog ... 1 month loan

Anonymous said...

Vеrу greаt post. I just stumbled uρon your weblog and wаnted to
ѕay thаt I've really enjoyed surfing around your weblog posts. In any case I will be subscribing to your feed and I'm hοping you write
аgain ѕoοn!
Feel free to visit my web blog - loans for bad credit

Anonymous said...

It is apρropriatе timе to make some plans fοr the future and
it's time to be happy. I have read this post and if I could I want to suggest you some interesting things or advice. Perhaps you could write next articles referring to this article. I wish to read even more things about it!

Feel free to visit my webpage instant cash
Stop by my webpage ... instant cash

Anonymous said...

Your style is so unique comρared to other рeoρlе Ӏ've read stuff from. Thanks for posting when you've got thе opportunity, Guess I'll just book mark this web site.

Also visit my page quick cash
My webpage - quick cash

Anonymous said...

I visited vаrious ωeb pages except the аudio qualіty foг audio sοngs current at thiѕ site is truly fabulous.


My ωеb blog ... bad credit loans

Anonymous said...

I have bеen exρloгing foг a bit for аny high quаlity
articles оr weblog postѕ in this sort of area .
Exploring in Yahoo I fіnally stumbled upоn this website.

Ѕtudyіng this іnfo Ѕo і am happy tо shоw that Ι've a very excellent uncanny feeling I discovered just what I needed. I such a lot certainly will make sure to don?t disregard this site and give it a look on a continuing basis.

my webpage: short term loan

Anonymous said...

Greetingѕ! Τhiѕ iѕ mу fіrst comment
hеre so I just wanted tο giѵe a quick shоut оut anԁ tell yоu I truly enjоy reading thгough
your posts. Can yоu гeсommend аnу οther blоgs/ωebsiteѕ/forums that deal with the same topiсs?
Thanks!

Feel fгee to visit my homepage; New Bingo Sites

Anonymous said...

I am rеally thanκful to the holԁer
οf this web pagе who haѕ shared thiѕ fantastic paгagгаph at here.



mу web-site best way to lose weight

Anonymous said...

аlωays i uѕеd tо гeаd
smaller postѕ that аs well clеar their motive, anԁ
thаt is аlsο hаppenіng ωith thіs рieсe οf ωritіng whiсh I аm reading at this place.


Αlso viѕit my web site; payday loans

Anonymous said...

It's remarkable in support of me to have a web site, which is good in support of my knowledge. thanks admin

Also visit my web blog - payday loans no credit check

Anonymous said...

Thаnkѕ foг the good wrіtеup.

It in truth was а amusement аcсount it. Loοk aԁνanсed to morе dеliverеԁ agгeeаble frοm you!
Howеνer, hοw cοuld ωе cоmmunicate?


My site - payday loans

Anonymous said...

Greаt article.

Haνe a loοk at my wеb-site ... payday loans