If, as the New Yuk Times tells us, a "nationwide shortage of several widely used anesthetics . . . has been exasperating doctors and veterinarians for months," then it certainly says nothing flattering about the American psycho psyche that the shortage didn't make the front page until it fucking got in the way of fucking killing people. Oh, good, okay, so now it's serious.
I mean, for a nation that goes around the world killing thousands upon thousands of people with robots and high-altitute aerial bombardment and white phosphorous incendiaries and depleted uranium munitions, our persistence in applying capital punishment to our own criminals (and not-criminals) is a very minor barbarism, and yet its clinicalization has got to be counted as a one of the weirder and creepier (and more revealing) aspects of our civilization. Yah, m'kay, we're gonna kill you, but we don't want it to hurt ya. That would be cruel. Talk about soothing moral platitudes. You're going to enact the ultimate cruelty, the most singularly irrevocable act of violence, and you're concerned that it's going to sting?
Thursday, September 30, 2010
Psycopathy
Labels:
Global Gulag,
Justice,
Prison Planet
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
15 comments:
Ow! Fucking fascist!
stay out of malibu, deadbeat!
I'm more a drawing-and-quartering man, myself.
Re: this and the next post - the gov't can put drugs in you to make you stop, but you can't put drugs in you to make you go.
BDR lol
Actually, interfering with justice is serious. As the article explains, the alternative is not using a medicine that stings; it is delaying the execution. Justice delayed is... what? Not exactly justice denied, but not justice, either.
By comparison, causing anesthesiologists to have to go with some less-desired anesthesia isn't that serious. I mean, the risk here is that they "leave patients groggier and with a higher risk of nausea and headaches". Not exactly front page of the NYT material, that.
You are of course right that nicely killing people makes no sense. And it is weird and creepy if you conceive of it as an individual's position. It is not: it's the mishmash result of innumerable meetings of committees, large and small. That's "democracy" for you.
I say hang 'em high, in public, and record it in hi def for youtube. If we are to use capital punishment, we ought to squeeze every bit of deterrent goodness out of it. Just "putting to sleep" scum like Letalvis Cobbins is much better than they deserve.
We have an Eighth Amendment bar on "cruel and unusual punishment," which has squeamishly been defined as "if it hurts too much." Note that we can torture away at will at Bagram, GTMO, etc., because, of course, THAT'S NOT PUNISHMENT, it's only "interrogation" and "intelligence gathering" and that sort of thing (and "the President has vast war powers that courts will not lightly interfere or intervene in"... etc.... etc....)
The significance of this drug thing is that as a local political issue, we loves our death penalty, so that if we can't implement it (and if this is the one drug that prevents the damned thing from hurting)... some local politicians have some 'splaining to do.
The thing that always gets ME about these executions is that the technician administering them ALWAYS WIPES THE CONDEMNED INMATE'S ARM DOWN WITH AN ALCOHOL SWAB. Always. Is the premise that the poor bastard might get an infection in the course of administering lethal poisons that are going to result in his (not cruel and unusual) death? THAT'S the part I find hilarious.
It's well documented that the least cruel method of human execution ever devised (aside from "not doing it") is none other than our friend the guillotine; of course, its French, and its all "icky" what with the head coming off and all... best we go with the quite literally antiseptic means of ersatz medical means we have now, I guess. An amazing society we are: not afraid to commit extraordinary acts of violence against those guilty of the heinous act of not being able to afford a good lawyer... but absolutely horrified of the thought of having to do it in an... icky way.
Sullivan's concerned that shooting would "give pleasure to those motivated by revenge or sadism". There's another motivation?
A shortage? I coulda sworn we had access to the Afghanistan poppy fields.
@10:21
"The NDP will tackle drug-related crime. Much of the opium produced in Afghanistan ends up on our streets causing misery and crime. Instead of trying to bomb the cultivators of the poppies from which Opium is produced, why don’t we just buy it all up and then either destroy it or use it for many of the medical conditions this drug apparently can help cure."
http://www.thenewdemocraticparty.co.uk/crime-too-soft-on.htm
I seem to remember reading about the Canadian NDP proposing the same thing.
You're going to enact the ultimate cruelty, the most singularly irrevocable act of violence, and you're concerned that it's going to sting?
The concern is for the peace of mind of the executioner, rather than the suffering of the victim.
"A shortage? I coulda sworn we had access to the Afghanistan poppy fields."
Gotta create phony shortages to keep prices high. CIA's just doing business, don't hate.
The death penalty may be wrong, by trying to carry it out in a humane manner is just sick!
Some of us had been threatening our friend Colby for a long time, because of the way he had been behaving. And now he'd gone too far, so we decided to hang him...
We have to compare executions as they are performed in the US to human sacrifices and not common judicial punishments . In the late iron age, before the Beowulf poem was written down, a criminal or enemy in war could expect to be chopped down without mercy, or hanged, burned alive, etc., Human Sacrifice in pre Christian times was a different matter. The Sacrificial victim was treated with great reverence, like a modern celebrity, there was a great deal of hand wringing and speechifying, and ritual observance. The victim was dying to pacify a terrible primal force, so that the community as a whole would be let off the hook for another few seasons, or years.
Post a Comment