People keep asking me why I post about Matthew Yglesias, who isn't exactly a moving target, and the only answer I have is that he is the most consistently ridiculous person in America. That is not to say that he is the most ridiculous--that prize probably goes to Victor/Victoria Perseus Thanatos Upanishad Velocity Hanson--but that he manages, day in and out, to maintain a steady, cruising velocity of Warp 6 on the what-the-fuck-is-he-talking-about scale. We already nabbed him once today.
Now he has returned to write a completely bonkers post called The Arbitrariness of Manufacturing, in which he posits that manufacturing is "not very rigorously defined." Well, okay, I mean, when does a pond become a lake? When is a creek a stream? When is a tree just a bush? He confuses agriculture with manufacturing and then confuses a farmer's market with a farm. He seems to think that the petrochemical companies manqués that produce fast food are not considered manufacturers, whereas he believes that the cooks at McDonald's fabricate the hamburger patties on-site. Thus armed with this quiver of soggy arrows, he suggests that we should not be quite so upset about the decline of manufacturing, because people will just switch to "manufacturing" blogs and McNuggets.
Of course, when people talk about the decline of manufacturing, what they are talking about is the decline of industries that produce durable goods of some enduring value. This is worrisome not because of the inherent desirability of cars and clock-radios and fridges and industrial steel over strawberries, hamburgers, and blawwwwgs, but because no alternate means of providing so large a segment of the population with a substantial, comfortable, long-term, maintainable income has emerged. The lesson of the ongoing cycle of economic busts is that you cannot employ every goddamn American as a middle assistant spend process materials operations director manager, and meanwhile, the absence of a labor-heavy industrial segment in our economy means that people must compete with each other for an ever-narrowing pool of precisely such fantastical job titles or else, uh, manufacture fries for nine bucks an hour and no sick days. Fuck you, Yglesias.
In the immediately preceeding post, entitled, Where Obama's Gone Wrong, Yggie writes:
But to give Obama critics their due, there’s a whole range of other topics on which I really do think the administration has been screwing up and where he’s largely been let off the hook. First and foremost in my mind has been the unaccountable delays in filling the vacant seats on the Federal Reserve Board.You know, I would've picked blowing up thousands of people with killer flying robots or expanding the global gulag of black prisons or conducting clandestine warfare throughout the Middle East, Africa, Latin America, and the Indian Subcontinent, or further hammering away at Habeas, or basically in general broadly speaking being the fucking Angel of Death itself in an earthly guise as a motivational seminar speaker, now available for YOUR corporate event. But, yeah, sure, you know, unaccountable delays in filling the vacant seats on the Federal Reserve Board, within the city limits . . . that ain't legal either.

