Tuesday, January 25, 2011

Hyrda Lacy

As Radley Balko, most prominently but certainly not solely, has now spent years demonstrating, American law enforcement has become increasingly paramilitary, largely on claims that the drug and terror wars require that police abandon their roles as general "officers of the peace" and community servants (beat cops, patrols) and criminal investigators (detectives) in order to become videogame strikeforces, knocking down doors, busting heads and taking names. So when I read about waves of violence striking police officers, I take a fairly dim view. A phrase twice-repeated in that article: serve an arrest warrant. Which sounds innocuous enough, but which now more often than not involves an armed SWAT team acting out a Call-of-Duty fantasy. Why was a SWAT team storming a house instead of just waiting the guy out? It's not like he had hostages.

17 comments:

Ethan said...

"Waves of violence striking police officers" is usually waves of victims striking back, and I say good, goddammit.

Anonymous said...

right, right, everyone's right. but it's still sad one of the two cops who died was in the canine unit.

Charles F. Oxtrot said...

I was saying it before He Who Measures Radiation, but no matter. It's true. The shift from "peace officer" to "law enforcer" is a huge one, perspective-wise... but a subtle one, culturally.

Peace officers see residents and transients as fellow humans, see their role as keeping peace among human equals. Equals.

Law enforcers see residents and transients as beneath those who make and enforce laws. Subjects, in other words.

It started in the 1970s with the deification of SWAT teams in a TV show dedicated to that notion.

Now we have a selection of something like 15 cop dramas you can watch on the TeeVee, all of them reminding you how superior the coppers are, how beautiful the ladycops, how manly-man-handsome the dudecops, how brilliant they are at reading the minds of the Unsubs.

What the FUCK is an "unsub"?

(I know. Please don't answer.)

I've never known a brilliant cop, nor even a half-smart one. Never.

Known plenty of eedjits with badges and guns and the authority of the state behind them, though.

mistah charley, ph.d. said...

Back in the twentieth century, we had a saying, "Your local police are armed and dangerous." And back then they weren't hopped up on steroids.

Anonymous said...

Give a man a hammer and everything looks like a nail.

drip

Anonymous said...

http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2011/01/24/AR2011012405326.html

zencomix said...

The link at RB's about the guy that got dragged out of a court room for wearing a hat is probably the most fucked up thing I have seen in quite a long time.

Leave free or die, indeed.

Blakenator said...

Charles, police departments don't want "smart" people, there was an article a couple of years ago about a guy who sued the local constabulary because they turned down his application because he was deemed "too smart." Or so the story went.
Take closer note of a lot of the stories of "violence toward cops" and you will find much of it could easily be called self defense if reported fairly.

Inkberrow said...

"More often than not" serving arrest warrants involves a SWAT team? Puhleeze. Sounds like Michelle Bachmann ad-libbing immigration "stats". The SWAT team in the Miami case arrived only after one of the two
(2) officers serving the warrant had been shot, confirming Lacy's homosuicidal state of mind.

Ah, the rites of blame allocation from rooting sections at mod-prog identity-politics melodramas. By the by, don't we need a post positing Russian airport security deficiencies as the proximate cause of this week's jihadist mass-murder plot?

IOZ said...

I would assume Russia's war in the Caucasus was the cause of the attack in Moscow.

LP Steve said...

St. Petersburg, not Miami. You're off by 250 miles. Not the first time, I'd wager.

Anonymous said...

"So when I read about waves of violence striking police officers, I take a fairly dim view."

Count me in on that.

They treat us like we are their enemies, so they shouldn't be surprised when we do the same.

Also, the criminal "justice"/prison system also has a role in this becoz many folks would rather die than pay a price for their alleged crime that is far more punitive than the sentence they get from the judge.

The violent living conditions of prisoners, which the government does nothing serious to stop, is essentially state advocated terror.

Z

Anonymous said...

"The violent living conditions of prisoners, which the government does nothing serious to stop, is essentially state advocated terror."

And it is used as such to gain leverage on the accused to accept plea bargains, testifying against others, manufacturing testimony against others, and whatnot.

It helps grease the rails for the justice system to process citizens thru the justice system quicker and it has ben going on for so long that it has become part of the design of our justice system: cruel and unusual punishment ... or the threat thereof ... that goes far beyond the sentence that is supposed to be limited by the law.

Z

Inkberrow said...

IOZ---

Cause as auspices takes us only so far, wouldn't you agree? Assigning primary moral responsibility is what we're usually about despite ourselves when we characterize a sequence of events. For instance, given your statement on Moscow, may we then say that Islamic terrorism caused Gitmo? Japanese intransigence caused Hiroshima? Selectively eliding the autonomous moral agency of the Russian airport mass-murderers or e.g. of Bush/Cheney reduces everything to will-to-power hurly-burly.

IOZ said...

I wouldn't agree.

Define "autonomous moral agency." Apply it to some act of "legal" or just war. See where that gets ya.

Mr.Fundamental said...

you thought, hey, a deadbeat, a loser, someone the square community won't give a shit about.

NutellaonToast said...

" Russia's war" wooohoooohoooo. Oh fun.

I love how this blog alternates between calling crazy people crazy, or else asking what it is the crazy people might get right? A democrat gets shot and it's just a nut job. Someone flies a plane into an IRS building and we're supposed to wonder why. What is his philosophy??! A suicide in Russia is only fighting back! A sex offender holed up in an attic is making a political stand!

I love how you can take a really good point and just slam it into a fucking concrete wall and then say "see how sharp this is now!! see!!!!!!" Then a minute later you'll tell someone else to calm down and be more careful.