Thursday, September 01, 2011

War Is a Farce that Gives Us Preening

I take it as a given that it is not the event which is an outlier, but the reporting of it.  So while you are constructing your elaborate morality pyramid in which the United States, however compromised, however violent in pursuit of its policy aims, at least isn't [insert enormity], well, basically, fuck you, you are worse than wrong.  The argument that the institutional violence the US pursues, its endless supposedly accidental slaughter, is by dint of some extraordinary claims about good intentions not simply less objectionable than "terrorism" or whatever bargain-rack Hitler you are fixated upon at this particular timeslot in cable history, but actually supportable as some kind of legitimate force of opposition to the amateur depredations of the Qaddafis of the world is simply laughable.  We avail ourselves of our army of conquest in order to take all those al-Assads' places; we are not merely Saddam's executioners, but his executors; this is the conqueror's doom, and it is why all our endeavors on this bloody field are in the most classical sense tragic--they aren't just awful, but also inexorable.

21 comments:

Montag said...

*than* "terrorism" ?

nothing worse than some bargain-rack dictator killing His Own People. it's better if we do it.

Anonymous said...

Who's preening?

http://www.nytimes.com/2011/09/01/opinion/kristof-from-libyans-thank-you-america.html?_r=1&hp

demize! said...

Sweet god, the comments.

Sorry said...

No puns or SF references seem appropriate here. Fucking sickening.

Walter Wit Man said...

Looking at the disgusting comments makes me have zero hope for America.

Americans are the most evil animals on earth. I wanted to sign in to give those people a taste of the hatred I have for them but don't do the google, etc.

Paul Alexander said...

Okay, before everyone here gets all riled up, do we know that there weren't any WMD's on their persons? WHAT ABOUT THE KNOWN UNKNOWNS? Besides, there were some fully grown, well armed, soldiers from the USA that have been killed in that country. So fair's fair.

Professor Coldheart said...

Look, if you can't tell the difference between a peasant farmer who was deliberately executed for getting in the way of a Sudanese militia and a Pashtun shepherd who was accidentally - accidentally! - set on fire by a U.S. predator drone, a shepherd who wouldn't have been, y'know, if he hadn't, it, hang on, sorry, losing the thread here.

Anonymous said...

some random syrian judge is claiming crimes against humanity. wonder how much the put in a swiss bank acct for him.

Paul Alexander said...

What I don't understand is why don't the people of Iraq, Iran, Afghanistan, the Entire Universe, Etc., seem to understand our rational? I mean it's not complicated! We went to your country because you were being bad little boys and girls. We do NOT like doing what we have to do. And then when we attempt to administer punishment, you start acting like a bunch of overindulged children, only armed to the teeth. "Stop or we'll keep killing your gladiators, your warriors, your lifeblood." And then you want us to treat you like adults?

It'd be really nice to think that someday our message will get through and we won't have to wear ourselves out improving other countries. Until then, we'll just have to suck it up and deal with ingrates making us look bad.

Anatole David said...

Pox Americana
Images rising like mushroom clouds in my head:


1.(Preeners-Sanctioning) A syphilitic turning up his prosthetic nose at the less monstrous.

2.(Preeners-Exuberant)Joyous clamor of imperial stenographers ejaculating praise= titillation of onanists awestruck by the beauty of the world's greatest snuff porn.

Anonymous said...

apropos;

some might enjoy this good beat down of zizek's tiring bullshit.

http://www.davidbordwell.net/essays/zizek.php

demize! said...

Please open your books to First Letter to the Zizekians.... Let us Bray..

Anonymous said...

The children visible in the picture you linked to were not shot in the head at close range. 'A man sees what he wants to see'.

demize! said...

Yes, a man does indeed. And you obtained your certification in Medical Pathology where?

The Mathmos said...

No a single troll to speechify about human nature and the inevitableness of massacres? I mean, it's as pertinent here as in the other thread, if you get my drift.

Paul Alexander said...

Oh those kids weren't killed by shots to the head? Then why are we wasting our time on them for?

Paul Alexander said...

Bullying ends at 12th grade, or when you pass your GED.

Anonymous said...

Earn more sessions by sleeving?

mark r. said...

War Is a Force that Gives Us Meaning
Chris Hedges

From Publishers Weekly
"The communal march against an enemy generates a warm, unfamiliar bond with our neighbors, our community, our nation, wiping out unsettling undercurrents of alienation and dislocation," writes Chris Hedges, a foreign correspondent for the New York Times. In War Is a Force That Gives Us Meaning, Hedges draws on his experiences covering conflicts in Bosnia, El Salvador and Israel as well as works of literature from the Iliad to Hannah Arendt's The Origins of Totalitarianism to look at what makes war so intoxicating for soldiers, politicians and ordinary citizens. He discusses outbreaks of nationalism, the wartime silencing of intellectuals and artists, the ways in which even a supposedly skeptical press glorifies the battlefield and other universal features of war, arguing not for pacifism but for responsibility and humility on the part of those who wage war.

From Library Journal
This moving book examines the continuing appeal of war to the human psyche. Veteran New York Times correspondent Hedges argues that, to many people, war provides a purpose for living; it seems to allow the individual to rise above regular life and perhaps participate in a noble cause. Having identified this myth, Hedges then explodes it by showing the brutality of modern war, using examples taken from his own experiences as a war correspondent in Latin America, the Middle East, and the Balkans. These examples highlight the devastating effects of war on life, community, and culture and its corruption of business and government. Hedges is not a pacifist, acknowledging that people need to battle evil, but he thoughtfully cautions us against accepting the accompanying myths of war.

karmanot said...

The 'exceptionalism' meme: Why do you make me hurt you? You know I love you. etc and so forth.

antonello said...

This is going to hurt me more than it hurts you. My back's just been killing me today. Giving you a thrashing is really going to aggravate it.