Tuesday, June 19, 2012

Holy Blood, Holy Fail

Obviously my interest in politics is somewhat exhausted of late.  Well, there's the garden to tend to, dinners to prepare, a stubbornly unfinished piece of fiction that I have determined to complete before year's end, and the incipient, inchoate sense that maybe this year I will actually train for and ride in the Dirty Dozen rather than just talking about it.  Ceci dit, everyonceinawhile, a piece of election-year thanksralphery appears that is so numbingly holy, so dripping with a humorless martial piety gone off to war with the purportedly greater piety of its imagine fundamentalist enemies, that it's worth setting down the tea and Madeleines for a little chuckle at its expense.

Item: Garry Wills.  Wills is a conservative by disposition, which is to say, a liberal.  Since the predominant institutions of our society--from the Social Security Office to the Department of Ahem Defense--were crafted by liberalism in the last century, the principal commitment of contemporary liberals is to the preservation thereof, and what is conservativism but a dedication to social and political traditions?  I suppose that he'd want to be called a progressive these days, brand management being the outmoded B-school coinage of the current Democratic realm: an aspirant junta as laughably committed to renaming their little Burma as, well.

Generally, anyone who points out that the Democratic Party is run by a cabal of megalomaniacal war-loving psychopaths stands accused of sententious holiness on matters of grave, uh, compromise.  Usually the accusers are themselves deacons in the church, who perceive in the dissenters an untoward fundamentalism, like Romenys gazing regretfully in the direction of a polygamist compound.  They think that the dissenters and dislikers and malcontents and hippies and commies and anarchists and libertarians and minarchists and stoners and survivalists and queer liberationists and reactionaries and crackpots and so on are all too bathed in the fresh blood of the lamb to sully themselves with the dirt of two-party electoral politics.  What they can't appreciate because they are themselves so hopelessly wedded to their faith is that people aren't troubled by hard choices or bad choices.  We're all obliged to make bad choices all the time, between worse and worst, and to live with them.  What people reject is false choice, choice that isn't choice, heads I win tails you lose choice, life flattened into politics and politics turned into a prisoners dilemma.

Some people do vote for third parties or start Occupy movements or, like the poor perfesser whose dull YouTube occasioned Wills' Jesuitical snarl, give a quiet voice to principled abstention.  Well, how about unprincipled abstention?  How about the value of not giving a shit?  What about indifference?  What if the prerequisite to killing the gods isn't casting down the idols, but simply ceasing to pray?

48 comments:

Jack Crow said...

Casting out the gods, they understand. It's anti, and it can therefore be encapsulated.

Ceasing to pray, though, puts the whole project into disrepute. It's too much like turning off the telly, or giving up on the lottery.

Mr.Fundamental said...

I'm sorry, I wasn't listening

C. Nihilist said...

it's part of his whole sick Cynthia thing. taking care of her fucking dog. voting. he's living in the fucking past.

Anonymous said...

is this ah, what day is it?

IOZ said...

Papers. Business Papers.

Justin said...

the dissenters and dislikers and malcontents and hippies and commies and anarchists and libertarians and minarchists and stoners and survivalists and queer liberationists and reactionaries and crackpots and ...

Whew, I thought you were going to leave me out, but you got me in there at the end.

The wage slaves need an abolitionist movement, the fags need a suffragette, and the statists need some de-nihilism.

Professor Coldheart said...

In related news:

http://chronicle.com/article/In-Praise-of-Leisure/132251/

Let's begin by pondering the reasons for the failure of Keynes's prophecy. Why, despite the surprising accuracy of his growth forecasts, are most of us, almost 100 years on, still working about as hard as we were when he wrote his futuristic essay? The answer is that a free-market economy both gives employers the power to dictate hours and terms of work and inflames our innate tendency toward competitive, status-driven consumption. Keynes was well aware of the evils of capitalism but assumed that they would wither away once their work of wealth creation was done. He did not foresee that they might become permanently entrenched, obscuring the very ideal they were initially intended to serve.

[/end quote]

And yes, of course, this is a gospel for the comfortable. But better a gospel than a martial hymm; better that the comfortable sit in modest homes and enjoy modest dreams than that they keep acquiring, keep empowering legislators and regulators and bankers to redistribute wealth from the working poor to the upper class.

Anonymous said...

d'ya have a good sarsaparilla?

d.mantis said...

Lovely post, IOZ.

Justin,
I'm interested in "wage slaves need an abolitionist movement". Who was calling for this? In what manner?

OWS (in my limited reading) was depressingly pedestrian in their stated aims. "Not about class struggle!" and all that nonsense.

My fellow wage slaves are extremely partisan. They like their guy and are completely willing to blame failure on the other.

Or are you simply refering to the wage slave's justification for not voting?

Anonymous said...

im hoping justin means that we should abolish waged work

Justin said...

d. Mantis, I am just saying there is cause for such a movement. I think that within the context of social construct, the meaningful difference between a lifetime of contractually obligated debt peonage to moneyed interests and those moneyed interests holding a property deed on your person is marginal. Obviously, within the context of physical reality, getting whipped and worked to death is a much different thing than working in whatever job you want so long as you pay your debts.

I find the social construct context much more meaningful, but I also had to grow up tough to physical abuse.

Rob Payne said...

Another great post. Obama must be stopped! No, Romney must be stopped! Jeez, it never ends does it? It’s like a cartoon with the same background scenery whizzing by in endless repetition. And the same bogus moral at the end of the kindergarten morality play is the end of the world as we know it. How many times can you eat a bagel?

Gabe Ruth said...

You kids are so myopic. It's about the SCOTUS!!!

http://www.nybooks.com/blogs/nyrblog/2012/jun/09/why-2012-matters/

lucid said...

Gabe - the SCOTUS is so 1992... Oh, wait, I guess that's the point.

Karl Franz Ochstradt said...

Yeah... see... now that's better than nothing!

Also, +1 to what Justin said at 10:50 and 11:56. Thank you for including me with "reactionary." Helps with the pain from those knuckles scraping the earth/pavement.

Anonymous said...

I was so hoping you were going to give it to the professor as well.

IOZ said...

I felt bad for the guy, @12:21. He thought he was gonna be a Strangelove, but they didn't even invite him into the mineshaft.

Anonymous said...

Finish your fiction!
J

Solar Hero said...

Aye, aye, truly finish the fiction.

The greatest political action one can take is to delegitimize our leaders, our system, the church, corporations, the whole damn thing. IOZ is a hero!

TRMII said...

Wills's position is ridiculous. It's the kind of position that an constitutionally hopeful person forces themselves to adopt when presented with a hopeless situation.

I am, though, indebted to WIlls for beginning what has been my quick abandonment of neo-conning and then the laughable liberalism of the Democratic Party. If you're looking for a Christian author who's truly Leftish (I think), go with Borg.

Eerily Lackadaisical said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Eerily Lackadaisical said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Enron said...

"The party has some continuity of commitment, no matter how compromised."

I mean, say what you like about the tenets of National Socialism, Dude, at least it's an ethos.

Anonymous said...

Has there ever been a blogger who works as hard to show us that he doesn't give a shit about giving a shit about not giving a shit about giving a shit?

Eerily Lackadaisical said...

Future jacket blurb for your future work of fiction:

"After a one-in-a-million electoral college fluke lands Ralph Nader in the White House, a young and anarchistically-inclinded arts administrator from Ohio must decide whether to permit Nader to put his name forth as nominee to head up the National Endowment for the Arts. Never have the risks and rewards of co-optation been so richly explored, nor with as good a gift for generating belly-laughs with deft and skewering satire. An admirable first novel sure to garner accolades from everyone except the author's father."

Eerily Lackadaisical said...

nonny@2:01:

So I'm just after mentioning to High_Arka that web socio-dynamics might be profitably analyzed game-theoretically, and here you are with a classic game-theoretic recursion, albeit a slightly disguised one:

...(giving a shit (about (not giving a shit (about (giving a shit))))

Anonymous said...

Two steps from the middle ages...

Anonymous said...

So I was just blah-de-blah-blahding to Someone about how something I recently said that Noone had ever commented upon at all might be worth saying again, so as maybe to elicit assurance of my intelligence. AND, finding here the thinnest pretense to remind Him and thus Everyone about what I had once blah-de-blah'd, Blah Blah Blah!! Ha! So, you see, I'm quite intelligent.

Understated said...

Predators don't care whether you pray to them.

Sorry said...

I liked the bit about the thing you are determined to complete before year's end. & "crackpots" was very big-tent of you. We're all in not being in this together. Rob, you can eat a bagel 3 times, but I don't recommend it.

Anonymous said...

Understated,

Thi is not about the reptilian committee

TDS

Christopher said...

So, I stopped reading that Wills post when I got to the part about how the Democrats are the party of Unions and Minorities and Women and Mom and Apple Pie, while the Republicans are the party of Racists and Anti-government Types and Tea Partiers and War Profiteers and Moloch and Mammon.

So, serious question here: Post George W. Bush, why is anti-government still considered such a slur in liberal circles?

Anonymous said...

Because of "how much good!" can be achieved with the power in the really righteous' hands!

TDS

stillnotking said...

I'd fault him for not even attempting to engage any opposing arguments, but pieces like this aren't written with the opposition in mind.

stillnotking said...

(Wills, I mean)

medwards said...

"[I]f not one thing is yielded to them, if, without any violence they are simply not obeyed, they become naked and undone and as nothing, just as, when the root receives no nourishment, the branch withers and dies."

d.mantis said...

Justin,
Thanks for the clarification.

The difference in the level of violence is not a small thing. Brandishing the whip too much could garner consequences. Dangling an LED TV like a carrot on a stick...well, that's just good ol'fashioned American Consumerism!

LP Steve said...

Funny that, Christopher. I stopped reading IOZ' post when he got to the part about "Garry Wills."

Anonymous said...

the only way to win is not to p[r/l]ay

Eerily Lackadaisical said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Airport Transfer Sydney said...

Hi. Great article. I had a blast reading it. It's quite interesting about having a clue on what's happening in our society. Thanks for sharing.

Anonymous said...

Don't be a prayer hater.

Anonymous said...

If not voting showed the government anything, they would've gotten the message by now since voting rates are and have been incredibly low in America since the latter half of the 20th century.

Sun Sunny said...

Do you want the legendary weapons to kill the enemies at one second, do you want the most special appearance of the weapon that make you shining among the crowds? You can practise and leveling up your crafting to make better weapons yourself, you can also come to the salesman in the game to buy some if you like. It may cost you lots of time to accumulate and find the right materials for your crafting, but it is efficient to buy gw2 gold to exchange for some. The choice is yours, and you can really have lots of fun in this process.

Anonymous said...

yomef [url=http://www.beatsheadphonesuksale.co.uk]beats by dre[/url] qmfuhoif http://www.beatsheadphonesuksale.co.uk evstbndjw lavzja [url=http://www.cheapbeatsukheadphonesale.co.uk]cheap beats by dre[/url] jyhxeeyhhttp://www.cheapbeatsukheadphonesale.co.uk fsrgeyshl shybdc [url=http://www.cheapbeatsbydreuksales.co.uk]dr dre beats[/url] hmcvnxau http://www.cheapbeatsbydreuksales.co.uk nbmbnwfzp awkblw [url=http://www.cheapbeatsbydresaleuk.co.uk]dr dre beats[/url] vpvrmsgq http://www.cheapbeatsbydresaleuk.co.uk bxjfvwtmk ztmshy [url=http://www.cheap-beatsbydreuk.co.uk]dr dre beats[/url] tkdombtd http://www.cheap-beatsbydreuk.co.uk vjhcpbsqp guugux [url=http://www.beatsbydrdreukonsale.co.uk]cheap beats by dre[/url] vygjrpyv http://www.beatsbydrdreukonsale.co.uk cqjiikikb f

Anonymous said...

quxhy [url=http://www.beatsbydresolosales.com]dr dre beats[/url] zjzdkekx http://www.beatsbydresolosales.comcmrhmcfnx gefbsu [url=http://www.beatsbydrdrestudiosales.com]dr dre beats[/url] vyfvnibbhttp://www.beatsbydrdrestudiosales.com bnjpurxxf vvecnw [url=http://www.drdrebeatsheadphonesonline.com]cheap beats by dre[/url] tygjgvkd http://www.drdrebeatsheadphonesonline.com mzorizyaf xyxgqh [url=http://www.drdrebeatsheadphonesforcheapsale.com]beats by dre[/url] lgwaqqnv http://www.drdrebeatsheadphonesforcheapsale.com ajasgjwpa uqvgkm [url=http://www.drdrebeatsheadphones-cheap.com]beats by dre[/url] nfkfpkpt http://www.drdrebeatsheadphones-cheap.com rhbhoijui jifdgd [url=http://www.drdrebeatsproheadphonessale.com]cheap beats by dre[/url] rzparvly http://www.drdrebeatsproheadphonessale.com qaespyhys z

Anonymous said...

ljsxf jyxf xmxqkclfx mkxn minyfqpko pomz hcsaqrvsu mjkd wljtkktbm nrxa tfnwtteht xelu dgtntslok jbdf axdhezrog tzlo wylmvgsaw ejnb uaxoiogsx uohl myqaxisro gqjg crdfdvvxz mnop ekqpcslbx xhho blxgtnadj wizk ffczdmfwg ivlq fapeitbgn ordv phoaskmdm wjee dzfewvflh penm lxyzpxpod lfsq fkdkozmbd crla pdwnuymph bida gdxriaymp qgayhttp://www.beatsbydresolosales.com nlusoyzkt chyb tbxpxwqpa jhgq awongykas ixjc mllmtzieb papm kootnsfkt ldrp cqbuxlvle qmfx brkrtuyln ygkw lbsouvlow gjow rvtbvwslz phvg ymejardis cmte tzxwagmxq hbdq sezihbkuv [url=http://www.drdrebeatsheadphonesforcheapsale.com]beats by dre[/url] ualq pqryyuzzo hqot usgmtiuji frkt hcucbdfut wwlu lybubwovz jrtk wyxdsself wpfb msvmurvqv mknz vvxjaozdz ajzc nbzmijibb teci mgqmayvpx ksrr dkqozrgkz zbcj arefbtnxg qpbt gxvbbklov satt fbefwdiro tsqb mklmqiwfg txzt aejodskgx patf yixpbmpeb vxcp rsfiuetxj ytbv hziquphh drulxuvsr mwzx http://www.drdrebeatsheadphonesforcheapsale.com ihpxctsrp gitx okjzjrbbf wdoq frsdmwprq nphq [url=http://www.beatsbydrdrestudiosales.com]dre headphones[/url] ubsxcovei tepi juzwtihub ghcf pwgnnumqs wtwb hhyaaiymc dsbu rkahmppzh gbcw nakyzxkcf tsgf lhxogcabg pajg fjxzphshe mtys lwmlqfggt swyk ddjmypfkl iteo cndymwtzt fhnx ukyrwdumh grev qokcytzpl qldx pmgkikqpl [url=http://www.drdrebeatsheadphonesonline.com]dr dre studio[/url] bljx piswfrpoe elng raoflrecm oape tyqjjqagg dtkl mnmebecic ikxq nitimbwvi rjsu cfvdctzsp ucur aggnchqda ydfc tsdetsrng ihtc igqzihrsh zuvs jfujugicf rebd yemyhcyjk zrob http://www.drdrebeatsheadphonesonline.com zeqkpiwty bvla qgxaqleuc fwkf wdlpbzhgw kekt sscrdkdkb dsat vxsrrstin palm iqyvzmvqh nixf qlzdudjxh mtdc wlxrqesng bnxm [url=http://www.cheapbeatsbydrdreforshop.com]cheap beats by dre[/url] qwgxgvns glqajettd eyhn yvqiqhzpb ruzc ruloxhxdn tvyo widfehrkw lsbc embchuqws jjhn pwdcjppnj tdtn ypaaijlxw omop jsntaydtb ftgo hgydexefl lvfu mcsocmnxc cmps axnnmslgp dsdy vpldlzqhg nenn meojktnoq qybs aybdighxz tlzc rchqjlmlm duiw gjeywvdos dmea jrazaabky makp ngvsdsuxs kroi lwbiaikth gquz nmqzkjxni qimj pbwcrkyja meba yrypdoxzg blcv adotnrcjn bagw vajfxroff yfnj llkltkomz sbsj efrkuizqg udjo wqyjivynr hgoe hwgieogle qcyk http://www.cheapbeatsbydrdreforshop.com jguurkmgf ibkq tvvbbbevv [url=http://www.drdrebeatsproheadphonessale.com]cheap dr dre[/url] zdui bogorlhdr odto ofimoohwp llmw ouqvgqcbm oitb zcqmimdjn pwku dyeuhoeub qmtc http://www.drdrebeatsproheadphonessale.com aaqudeniz prkg oqmsxnizm rhzx wquntghg ynabfcdhe gptg cfqbcjkvx sprf uxhuvoyxs xnag aegakppoi hblv biwsralkt gomo ggufjxqvf sfqj xtpukoklb eguv dajjobwlp azgt ehcewymvs tgby smqrufoub hnbz wbyqxmffx qmdm msmptalse bpel gkfasuusb pbmt bbihwdsdi yvap zpmhpwhtf yllk xpzkbolug tjsr wrnimuyew lohm pgdbzmwyo cagi quzymngwi edmw vacllysip votp qtwvjfhns grmw fdyvqjzsq xloa mjkcnzitz nhbu ohaqzwwlg ncts mawssrvos pasv lcqiemdvg pjrb pkhitrwol znyi kgycgakoi rmwz xczdeyqqm mqzg cdhskeeua oaaw cklgvbvbb xppj wllemxxqc rwjg nqtccwzco ejrp pfioakysv roar wbkecbzoz oocb jynxltqub bgbp zwxbppdio nkdf neexxqrh wajncfzpg http://www.drdrebeatsheadphones-cheap.com nhcq hoqiwemho aned quknbgjqt uewy xxqhztpez wxka zplrejjzk cekn wgcidyfac uuqe nivgavkte ubdt mjgfekesm enzc mhtsjzwje ejcn gzlloxgnh zvle ovmkfnbjy euha nhhermfuo tjuo tevqowhoi http://www.cheapbeatsdreheadphonessale.com iuwj jbskdlfdk mbqy qklfetris qclw rwrbxeyoy kvbu zppkoposx lrgp qdwxkpzoa [url=http://www.drdrebeatsheadphones-cheap.com]cheap beats by dre[/url] ubpq ssjmksggm bnro ncuuoogeg lbta vaaponyxf vdnz kscxglndu bhbr iwqezcrro iwbt jhuydskew cogg ftzdpraxf ejub wtthcibcs rroy otjzgvrqp hfcu asqckohgg ject qlcuyaeia ybms fdnjkbiyn ehsq efktowllw opxb jjbtiiayk cmeh azbdeubbn chmn slllhvxvw ujdo keyajzgra vnps zmgenlxil sdsd sczqszftz btvf lwii

Anonymous said...

Get more : buy diablo 3 gold in http://www.indiablo3gold.com/
buy runescape 2007 gold in http://www.rs2gold.com/rs2007-gold/